154
votes
Is it ok to upload joke papers to arXiv?
There is a long tradition of posting joke papers to arXiv on or around April Fool's Day, especially in astro-ph - see the list below. The fact that all these papers were approved for arXiv offers some ...
105
votes
When someone cites one of your papers, is it a good idea to send an email to the authors to show appreciation?
Straight answer: NO it's not a good idea
Citing someone is (and should) be neither a favor nor a gesture of politeness. So there's no point to send a thank you email. Thanking someone for a citation ...
- 11.7k
78
votes
Accepted
Should I ask my co-author before I upload an article (that he already told me is okay to publish) to arXiv?
Yes, you should check with any co-authors before publicly posting a preprint of work that is not yet published.
They may prefer that you not post it at this time (e.g. if they have a particular ...
- 110k
78
votes
What are the downsides of using arXiv references instead of conference/journal references for the same paper?
Using arXiv instead of a conference / journal reference has an obvious disadvantage: readers won't know that the paper eventually passed peer review and was published. This is important context, ...
- 135k
74
votes
Is it ethical to upload an automatically generated paper to a non peer-reviewed site as part of a larger research?
"Shall I poison a well to see how many drink out of it?"
Frankly, the idea of debunking review processes is not that new, and the latest wave started with the Sokal hoax. There were a couple of ...
- 52.8k
73
votes
Accepted
IEEE conference chair asked to take down the arXiv version of the paper within 24 hours
I think that what you're seeing here is a conference chair who doesn't understand what arXiv is and is blindly applying the self-plagiarism policy.
The IEEE's current official FAQ on author rights has ...
- 191k
66
votes
Accepted
Should I endorse someone on arXiv who emailed me randomly?
It seems clear that you are not obligated to act in any particular way here. But since the author has published other work in a reputable journal and since the current submission looks like ...
- 132k
65
votes
Should I ask my co-author before I upload an article (that he already told me is okay to publish) to arXiv?
Submitting to ArXiv is a form of publication. You always need the consent of all coauthors to publish anything, anywhere.
- 34.1k
65
votes
Accepted
How does one go about writing papers as a nobody?
If what you put on arXiv is worthless to scholars then no, it won't be sufficient. And you need an account there first and that, I believe, still requires an endorser from academia.
Before you write a ...
- 399k
61
votes
Accepted
Should an undergraduate claim ownership of their article uploaded on arXiv?
Congratulations on your paper!
You don't have to, but it would be a good idea to make an arXiv account and use it to claim ownership of the paper. This will make it easier for people to find your ...
- 135k
61
votes
What are the differences between viXra.org and arXiv.org?
arXiv.org is a multi-institutional e-print repository funded by universities and other research organisations costing hundreds of thousands of dollars to run. It's purpose is rapid dissemination of ...
- 1,360
60
votes
Accepted
Why is it forbidden by the IEEE to post 'author-submitted' papers on ArXiv?
what is the logic between allowing preprints, but not author-submitted papers?
There is no logic behind this. It is part of the culture of publishers who want to restrict access as much as possible, ...
- 11k
57
votes
How do you validate the credibility of arXiv cited papers in IEEE conferences?
No, I don't think this is appropriate.
Citation is about giving proper credit. If an author uses something from an arXiv submission to motivate a way they identify or approach a problem or the ...
- 135k
48
votes
Accepted
Can I submit my paper to arXiv with a header that says "Under review at X" when it isn't?
Remove it. It is not appropriate to mislead people as to the submission or publication status of your paper. You should also remove any other reference to the conference appearing in the paper (e.g. ...
- 135k
47
votes
I mistakenly chose the CC BY 4.0 license on arxiv. Can anyone take my paper and publish it in a journal or conference?
Can anyone publish my paper in a journal or conference?
They'd need to attribute the paper to you. Most journals will only accept papers written by the person who is submitting the paper.
Can a ...
- 567
45
votes
Accepted
How to take the endorsement request for arXiv?
First of all
The mail to me was also cc-ed to some big persons in top-ranked universities.
For me this would already be a red flag and result in not endorsing them. The Arχiv explicitly instructs ...
- 65k
45
votes
What are good reasons for declining to referee a manuscript that hasn't been posted on arXiv?
In my view this would be downright unethical.
If you don't have time to review, just say so. If the title and abstract aren't interesting to you, decline on that basis. Nobody's making you review it, ...
- 1,475
44
votes
Accepted
Do we cite results in Arxiv which are obviously wrong?
Disclaimer: I have very limited experience, so what follows may not accurately reflect professional conventions. That said, from my limited experience I think it does.
EDIT: Disclaimer the second: ...
- 692
43
votes
Is it ok to upload joke papers to arXiv?
Uploading joke papers to arXiv does not violate arXiv policy, according to this email sent by the arXiv moderation:
---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: arXiv Moderation Date: Mon, Mar 13,...
43
votes
Accepted
Why are journals used in modern scientific academic research?
Why are so many people publishing [on ArXiv]?
You have to be careful with terminology when making statements like that. ArXiv is certainly "publishing" in the literal sense of "making public" but ...
- 34.1k
43
votes
Accepted
Pre-print service like arXiv but with private option, so I can correct my mistakes without publicly advertising my mistakes?
Basically, if I understand you correctly, you want proof of priority without publishing.
Well, this problem is well known from middle-ages and renaissance where people wanted to be able to prove they ...
- 52.8k
42
votes
How does one go about writing papers as a nobody?
I largely agree with Buffy's answer, but I want to emphasize something else. The OP writes that they want "bragging rights" and to make their college application look better. This is exactly ...
- 8,116
41
votes
Is it ok to upload joke papers to arXiv?
The arXiv (pronounced "archive")is a repository of electronic preprints, known as e-prints, of scientific papers in the fields of mathematics, physics, astronomy, computer science, quantitative ...
- 8,269
41
votes
Accepted
When someone cites one of your papers, is it a good idea to send an email to the authors to show appreciation?
No, because citation is a matter of transparency to scholarship generally...
No, one does not "thank" someone for citing one's paper. An academic author is obliged to cite a paper when he/...
- 659
40
votes
How does one go about writing papers as a nobody?
"I want to make a film. I never made a movie, directed a play, managed people and have no idea what to make the movie about" - this would be the analogy of what you talk about.
Most ...
- 52.8k
39
votes
What are the differences between viXra.org and arXiv.org?
arXiv is a respected repository for physics and math preprints. In some fields of physics, it is actually the primary venue through which new papers are read.
viXra is a site for people, almost ...
- 21.1k
38
votes
Is arXiv really a lower form of publication than the majority of computer science journals?
The standard for the arXiv is "looks like an actual paper on the first glance". So the fact that a preprint appeared on the arXiv isn't really adding any respectability to it that a ...
- 48.7k
38
votes
Accepted
Is arXiv really a lower form of publication than the majority of computer science journals?
First, arXiv is hosted at Cornell but this does not mean it’s moderated by Cornell people (that may be true in CS but it’s not true in physics, where the pool of moderators is quite wide).
Next, ...
- 28.5k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible