1

Why do people studying e.g. Business Administration (or similar) receive BSc or MSc degrees? Those guys don't rely on the scientific method even if they may use some mathematical or scientific tools from social sciences sometimes.

Is this just an institutional artifact?

  • 1
    I am not sure about Bachelors degree. But, I always thought MBA means Masters of Business Administration. I never heard of MBA is considered MSc. Would you please clarify by giving some examples? – scaaahu Oct 19 '16 at 11:57
  • 1
    Master's of Science in Business Administration at Boston University. There are many, many others, too. – Teusz Oct 19 '16 at 12:02
  • @Teusz have you looked at the BU BSc curriculum? It seems to me that most of the core classes are "science". – StrongBad Oct 19 '16 at 15:20
  • This question is poorly worded. Are you asking is Business Administration a science? – h22 Oct 19 '16 at 19:16
  • 2
    "those guys don't rely on the scientific method", sorry but this is just plain ignorant. While there are likely exceptions (you will find examples in STEM also), those guys does indeed rely on scientific methods. I can't believe that this is a good faith question – Repmat Oct 19 '16 at 19:54
3

Somee University's have found that they actually had no policy to differentiate why some degrees were only offered as a BA or as BS and decided to create (or at least formally define) a difference, like this story:

BA/BS, Difference Between Degrees

Background: in 1984, the Academic Senate Curriculum Committee was asked to prepare a policy statement which would differentiate between Bachelor of Science degrees and Bachelor of Arts degrees at California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo. The need for this arose when some departments at Cal Poly proposed to change their B.A. degrees to B.S. degrees. The requests were refused by the Chancellor's Office in part because Cal Poly, SLO, had no campus policy which specified the differences between the two degrees.

This one University created this type of distinction:

Bachelor of Arts Degree:

  • is usually less specialized than a Bachelor of Science degree.
  • requires a minimum of 180 quarter units for the degree; 36 units are required in the major, of which at least 18 units are at the 300-400 level.
  • is normally awarded in such majors as the languages, literature, other humanities, and history.

Bachelor of Science Degree:

  • typically involves technical fields.
  • requires a minimum of 180 quarter units for the degree; 54 units are required in the major, of which at least 27 quarter units are at the of 300-400 level.
  • is normally awarded in such majors as the physical and biological sciences, engineering, and agriculture

Here's a different take on the same issue:

The BA is a liberal arts degree intended to develop skills and talents essential to succeeding in a global society. It combines study of the arts, humanities, historical perspectives, and the natural and social sciences with advanced critical inquiry and an in-depth knowledge in an academic discipline (major). The program develops cultural, social, and political literacy, including the abilities to communicate effectively and clearly in writing and in speech, and to understand on a basic level a world language other than one’s own.* In so doing, it fosters the ability to understand and actively participate in discourses both within and beyond the field of your major (such as a minor or second major), and it promotes engagement with cultural, social, and political difference.

The BS is a liberal arts degree intended to develop skills and talents essential to professional work. It combines study of the arts, humanities, historical perspectives, and the natural and social sciences with advanced critical inquiry and an in-depth knowledge in a specific academic discipline (major). The program develops an understanding of empirical analysis, scientific methodology and protocols, and mathematics and quantitative techniques. In so doing, it equips you for continued engagement in professional research within your chosen field.

What's the actual difference in terms of coursework, other than the choice of major itself? The BA requires a foreign language (2 semesters) and a few extra humanities classes, while the BS has no requirement for foreign language but adds an extra natural science lab and extra math class. It's mostly a nonsense differentiation that means nothing, but it sounds fancy and gives the illusion of choice if you don't know why you want to go to college - so it's an effective part of the marketing to some audiences.

But in all of these note that no mention is made of the scientific method, math, or any classically recognized type of 'art' (such as painting, literature, etc). The words art and science are not well defined in this way across academia, and so in the end they are used in whatever way the school decides they want to use them.

There are some other classifications in use as well, such as bachelors of: music (BM), applied science (BAS), fine art (BFA), and even a Bachelor Of Business Administration (BBA).

One final note is the classification sometimes ends up purely as a result of what 'school' or 'college' within the University grants the degree. Some schools define themselves as liberal arts/humanities schools and only offer a BA, some define themselves as technical/technology schools and only grant a BS, business schools are more likely to offer something branded as a BBA/MBA, schools of "letters and science" often offer both, etc. In such schools the difference is who is in charge of that particular degree, more than it reflects a genuine difference in what the classification means to students or other community members.

And all of this is just in the US system!


TLDR; The difference in a BA/BS and how "business administration" will be classified (as BA, BS, BBA, etc) means something only within the context of a given school, varies widely between schools, and sometimes means nothing. Each institution generally chooses for itself what, if any, difference there is, so you'll need to refer to each school for reasoning on why they do things they way they do - and sometimes the answer will just be tradition. 'Art' and 'science' in academic degrees don't necessarily mean the same thing as they do in the vernacular.

  • 2
    IIRC, when I was in undergrad at my university, even the "pure" sciences (e.g. Physics, Chemistry, Biology) were awarded BA's and only engineering degrees were BS's. – pwcnorthrop Oct 19 '16 at 21:23
0

At University of Essex they provide both degrees, and they even give an explanation of the differences. It boils down to the following:

An MBA in Business Administration:

  • Takes it's starting point in the student's previous work experience
  • Focuses on tools rather than theory

An MSc on the other hand:

  • Is accessible to people without prior work experience (more like a normal education)
  • Takes it's starting point in theory

More informally, an MBA is often for people who cannot advance further in their career without an academic degree of some sort.

Does that now mean you should regard BA as an academic degree in the same way as eg. chemistry or physics? No, but different subjects has different traditions, and it is generally not very fruitful to play the 'subject x is not a real science'-game.

0

Professional degrees

Professional degrees are a thing, and MBA is generally considered one of them. They are similar but a bit different from the 'general' academic degrees - they follow a similar structure, studies and rankings but one of the main differences is that professional studies will generally focus on acquisition of a large amount of domain knowledge (whether that domain is business administration, pharmacy, dentistry, surgery, engineering or law) and only a minority of students at the very end of their careers will work on what would be "truly" science.

However, those fields have solid traditions that are often older than whole academic disciplines, so they have always been parts of higher education. The details will differ between countries - some will call all of them as 'masters', some will have specific naming for each subfield, and some will explicitly have two 'tracks', differentiating between MSc and the various professional masters degrees.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.