7

I have submitted a manuscript to a journal, but after 14 months they have not given me any answer while I have sent email to them many times. Now, What can I do?

(I only received a revision 12 months ago, and after I sent the revise version of the manuscript, I have not received any response. Also, a mailed them many times to everyone who I can find his/her email, but no response. It's current status is under review.)

  • Have to tried contacting the publisher or calling someone in charge of the journal? – Kimball Jun 27 '16 at 6:13
  • Have they not responded at all? Or have they responded with "in review"? Is it a topic with significant theoretical components (which may take time)? – Captain Emacs Jun 27 '16 at 7:06
  • 3
    Please register your account so that you can edit and comment on your own question. You may also need to follow these instructions to merge your two accounts. – ff524 Jun 27 '16 at 7:45
  • Can you clarify your question. The first part implies that you you submitted a manuscript for the first time and have waited 14 months. Then you say something about it being a revise and resubmit and waiting 12 months. – Jeromy Anglim Feb 20 '17 at 23:53
5

I was an ejournal senior editor for four years. Although few of them are really professionally acceptable, there are numerous confounding factors that can cause a break between an editor and authors. These include unanticipatable reviewer declines, lingering sponsoring institution policy changes including threatened journal cancellations, journal management system breakdowns, and of course, gross editor mismanagement. A submitting author should hold a journal to a published timeline (including any extensions the editor requests and the author formally accepts) and withdraw their manuscript quickly for resubmission elsewhere if that timeline or negotiated extensions) isn't being met. This withdrawal should be written (electronically is fine) with copies to the Journal editor AND the Department Head of the sponsoring department/institution. An acknowledgement from either is to be welcomed but not necessary to terminate the relationship and allow the author to move on. When resubmitting elsewhere, an author may be requested to submit evidence of previous submission termination. I only made this request once (out of 300 manuscript submissions) and it was willingly supplied.

0

In your conditions I would withdraw the paper. Find the editor surface mail and send a formal withdraw letter explaining your reasons and precisely says that if you have no answers within a month you will consider your paper as withdrawn.

Send the same letter to the editor via email. Wait a month and in case of no answer start submitting elsewhere.

It arrived to a friend. After the surface mail letter, the editor answer that the paper for some unknown reason was simply lost!

It arrives, we can simply hope that it won't arrive too frequently ;-)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.