-1

I submitted a survey paper to ACM Computing Surveys over four months ago. When I contacted the journal, they told me they had difficulty securing reviewers. I'm okay with that, but I am curious if that is a typical experience for this journal. I tried looking online but couldn't find reliable sources on how long the journal usually takes to review submissions.

  • How did it take for you to receive a review from ACM Computing Surveys?
  • Is that indicative of my chances of being accepted for submission?
New contributor
Nathan Gavenski is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
0

1 Answer 1

0

How did it take for you to receive a review from ACM Computing Surveys?

I have not submitted to this journal in a long time, but I have reviewed for them on occasion.

ACM Computing Surveys publishes (typically long and intricate) survey papers. Consequently, they give the authors (for computer science) relatively long time to review (by default 8 weeks I believe). Additionally, it's not a stretch to believe that finding reviewers for such papers is even more difficult than for normal research articles.

In general, 4 - 6 months until first decision is fairly normal for a high-profile computer science journal. I don't see anything out of the expected in what you describe.

Is that indicative of my chances of being accepted for submission?

No. Review time is not indicative of your chances to get accepted (outside of the obvious case of a quick desk reject). Weak papers take approximately as long to review as very strong ones, and the main driver of delays is anyway how long it takes the editor to herd together a sufficient number of reviewers.

If anything, a long review time is indicative that your topic is sufficiently niche (or you have enough conflicts of interest) that the editor is struggling more than usual to find reviewers. But the Editor-in-Chief already told you as much.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .