I just finished my second attempt at the GRE General after a 2.5 month interval and my Verbal score suffered due to an unscheduled bathroom break and me thinking that that verbal section was for their research purposes and wouldn't be scored. I got 156 in Verbal and 168 in quant and I expect 5 or 5.5 in my essays. For a PhD math admission committee would this score be preferred over my previous score of 161 verbal, 164 quant and 4.5 essay, even though the total is one less?
I already have a 115/120 TOEFL ibt score that could somewhat cover for my poor verbal score here. Also, my GRE subject test in math didn't go too well and while the results are still awaited, I think this would give me another reason to prefer my latest GRE score with higher quant marks.
I've chosen to report both scores to all the universities but some of them ask for one set of unofficial scores listed by the student in the application. So which ones should I choose to mention?