Skip to main content
Academia

Return to Question

Tweeted twitter.com/StackAcademia/status/1569340065167417344
Became Hot Network Question
edited tags
Link
Med Med
Med Med
  • 2.4k
  • 15
  • 33
Corrected spelling
Source Link
Snijderfrey
Snijderfrey
  • 9.4k
  • 2
  • 31
  • 52

I have received the decision on a manuscript that iI have submitted. The editor in chief decided to reject the paper stating that the reviewers are advising against the publication of the manuscript.

There were four reports, two suggesting minor revisions and publication of the paper. The other two reports had major concerns which are not related to the submitted manuscript, which lead me to believe that they were sent to us by mistake.

Are these kinds of mistakes possible by the editor? How should iI contact the editor in order to get some clarifications?

I have received the decision on a manuscript that i have submitted. The editor in chief decided to reject the paper stating that the reviewers are advising against the publication of the manuscript.

There were four reports, two suggesting minor revisions and publication of the paper. The other two reports had major concerns which are not related to the submitted manuscript, which lead me to believe that they were sent to us by mistake.

Are these kinds of mistakes possible by the editor? How should i contact the editor in order to get some clarifications?

I have received the decision on a manuscript that I have submitted. The editor in chief decided to reject the paper stating that the reviewers are advising against the publication of the manuscript.

There were four reports, two suggesting minor revisions and publication of the paper. The other two reports had major concerns which are not related to the submitted manuscript, which lead me to believe that they were sent to us by mistake.

Are these kinds of mistakes possible by the editor? How should I contact the editor in order to get some clarifications?

deleted 6 characters in body
Source Link
Med Med
Med Med
  • 2.4k
  • 15
  • 33

I have received the decision on a manuscript that i have submitted. The editor in chief decided to reject the paper stating that the reviewers are advising against the publication of the manuscript.

There were four reports, two suggesting minor revisions and publication of the paper. The other two reports had comments addressing whichmajor concerns which are not related to the submitted manuscript, which lead me to believe that they were sent to us by mistake.

Are these kinds of mistakes possible by the editor? How should i contact the editor in order to get some clarifications?

I have received the decision on a manuscript that i have submitted. The editor in chief decided to reject the paper stating that the reviewers are advising against the publication of the manuscript.

There were four reports, two suggesting minor revisions and publication of the paper. The other two reports had comments addressing which are not related to the submitted manuscript, which lead me to believe that they were sent to us by mistake.

Are these kinds of mistakes possible by the editor? How should i contact the editor in order to get some clarifications?

I have received the decision on a manuscript that i have submitted. The editor in chief decided to reject the paper stating that the reviewers are advising against the publication of the manuscript.

There were four reports, two suggesting minor revisions and publication of the paper. The other two reports had major concerns which are not related to the submitted manuscript, which lead me to believe that they were sent to us by mistake.

Are these kinds of mistakes possible by the editor? How should i contact the editor in order to get some clarifications?

Source Link
Med Med
Med Med
  • 2.4k
  • 15
  • 33