Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackAcademia/status/832013066103570432

Is it Okay, if Iokay to submit the revised manuscript very early towell before the due date?

Recently I received comments from two reviewers ofon my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointedgiven a few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. Why didn't you do it?

DueThe due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier tothan the due date?

If yes, whether it will it give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am also not interested to includein including it in this manuscript.

Is it Okay, if I submit the revised manuscript very early to due date?

Recently I received comments from two reviewers of my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointed few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. Why didn't you do it?

Due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier to due date?

If yes, whether it will give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am also not interested to include it in this manuscript.

Is it okay to submit the revised manuscript well before the due date?

Recently I received comments from two reviewers on my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have given a few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. Why didn't you do it?

The due date is 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier than the due date?

If yes, will it give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me work on comment number 4. I am also not interested in including it in this manuscript.

removed unrelated phrases.
Source Link
Kay
  • 6.5k
  • 8
  • 44
  • 71

Recently I received comments from two reviewers of my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointed few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?

Due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "This is Okay!! Why"Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier to due date?

If yes, whether it will give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am also not interested to include it in this manuscript.

Recently I received comments from two reviewers of my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointed few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?

Due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier to due date?

If yes, whether it will give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am also not interested to include it in this manuscript.

Recently I received comments from two reviewers of my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointed few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. Why didn't you do it?

Due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier to due date?

If yes, whether it will give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am also not interested to include it in this manuscript.

typo error
Source Link
Kay
  • 6.5k
  • 8
  • 44
  • 71

Recently I received comments from two reviewers of my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointed few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?

Due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier to due date?

If yes, whether it will give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am not also not interested to include it in this manuscript.

Recently I received comments from two reviewers of my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointed few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?

Due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier to due date?

If yes, whether it will give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am not also not interested to include it in this manuscript.

Recently I received comments from two reviewers of my submitted manuscript as major revision. Both the reviewers have pointed few major comments along with some minor comments. The major comments are something like this:

  1. It is essential to analyse.
  2. Please add some more explanation on this.
  3. Please discuss with xyz method and check the difference in the results.
  4. This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?

Due date is given by 45 days.

I finished the first 3 major comments in a week. However, I have planned to work on comment number 4 as my future research. I had also mentioned about it in the manuscript before submission. But still one reviewer commented as "This is Okay!! Why didn't you do it?" So I have explained little more about it (why am I skipping it here) in the revised manuscript.

Now my question is, can I submit the revised manuscript now? Isn't it very early i.e. 38 days earlier to due date?

If yes, whether it will give a bad impression that I have another 6 weeks, still I am skipping to work on the comment number 4?

Note: The reviewer has not told me to do work on the comment number 4. I am also not interested to include it in this manuscript.

Source Link
Kay
  • 6.5k
  • 8
  • 44
  • 71
Loading