Looking through google news feed just now I see an item that links directly to Science with the url https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095 which combines science.org with a DOI. At the moment the page is empty - it contains a header and footer of the usual Science links but no article in the middle - a zombie page.

Other popular scientific news websites link to the same empty page when announcing what at least PubMed summarizes as An extremely energetic cosmic ray observed by a surface detector array, gives the abstract and links to a doi that then goes to the zombie page.

What's so exciting is that a single 240 exa-electron volt (240E+18 eV) charged particle (possibly a proton or light nucleus, until it hit our atmosphere) had the kinetic energy of a tennis ball!

In the past (often in phys.org news items) I've clicked on links in popular scientific news articles that go directly to doi.org's "appology page" indicating that the number has not yet been assigned or linked.

In a half-day or so, these same links start working, so I need to save them and check them later.

Question: How do popular scientific news outlets and google news get doi and doi-like links that lead to zombie pages when first release, but only later actually link to the intended scientific paper?

I'm interested in both:

1. the mechanism by which a doi is issued that doesn't work but will work in the future
2. why, in 2023 this still happens

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095

Screen Shot 2023-11-25 at 9.02.52 AM.png (UTC+08):

Looking through google news feed just now I see an item that links directly to Science with the url https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095 which combines science.org with a DOI. At the moment the page is empty - it contains a header and footer of the usual Science links but no article in the middle - a zombie page.

Other popular scientific news websites link to the same empty page when announcing what at least PubMed summarizes as An extremely energetic cosmic ray observed by a surface detector array, gives the abstract and links to a DOI that then goes to the zombie page.

What's so exciting is that a single 240 exa-electron volt (240E+18 eV) charged particle (possibly a proton or light nucleus, until it hit our atmosphere) had the kinetic energy of a tennis ball!

In the past (often in phys.org news items) I've clicked on links in popular scientific news articles that go directly to doi.org's "appology page" indicating that the number has not yet been assigned or linked.

In a half-day or so, these same links start working, so I need to save them and check them later.

Question: How do popular scientific news outlets and google news get DOI and DOI-like links that lead to zombie pages upon first release, but only later actually link to the intended scientific paper?

I'm interested in both:

1. the mechanism by which a DOI is issued that doesn't work but will work in the future
2. why this still happens in 2023

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095

Screen Shot 2023-11-25 at 9.02.52 AM.png (UTC+08):

Looking through google news feed jsut now I see an item that links directly to Science with the url https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095 which combines science.org with a DOI. At the moment the page is empty - it contains a header and footer of the usual Science links but no article in the middle - a zombie page.

Other popular scientific news websites link to the same empty page when announcing what at least PubMet summarizes as An extremely energetic cosmic ray observed by a surface detector array, gives the abstract and links to a doi that then goes to the zombie page.

What's so exciting is that a single 240 exa-electron volt (240E+18 eV) charged particle (possibly a proton or light nucleus, until it hit our atmosphere) had the kinetic energy of a tennis ball!

In the past (often in phys.org news items) I've clicked on links in popular scientific news articles that go directly to doi.org's "appology page" indicating that the number has not yet been assigned or linked.

In a half-day or so, these same links start working, so I need to save them and check them later.

Question: How do popular scientific news outlets and google news get doi and doi-like links that lead to zombie pages when first release, but only later actually link to the intended scientific paper?

I'm interested in both:

1. the mechanism by which a doi is issued that doesn't work but will work in the future
2. why, in 2023 this still happens

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095

Screen Shot 2023-11-25 at 9.02.52 AM.png (UTC+08):

Looking through google news feed just now I see an item that links directly to Science with the url https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095 which combines science.org with a DOI. At the moment the page is empty - it contains a header and footer of the usual Science links but no article in the middle - a zombie page.

Other popular scientific news websites link to the same empty page when announcing what at least PubMed summarizes as An extremely energetic cosmic ray observed by a surface detector array, gives the abstract and links to a doi that then goes to the zombie page.

What's so exciting is that a single 240 exa-electron volt (240E+18 eV) charged particle (possibly a proton or light nucleus, until it hit our atmosphere) had the kinetic energy of a tennis ball!

In the past (often in phys.org news items) I've clicked on links in popular scientific news articles that go directly to doi.org's "appology page" indicating that the number has not yet been assigned or linked.

In a half-day or so, these same links start working, so I need to save them and check them later.

Question: How do popular scientific news outlets and google news get doi and doi-like links that lead to zombie pages when first release, but only later actually link to the intended scientific paper?

I'm interested in both:

1. the mechanism by which a doi is issued that doesn't work but will work in the future
2. why, in 2023 this still happens

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095

Screen Shot 2023-11-25 at 9.02.52 AM.png (UTC+08):

Looking through google news feed jsut now I see an item that links directly to Science with the url https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095 which combines science.org with a DOI. At the moment the page is empty - it contains a header and footer of the usual Science links but no article in the middle - a zombie page.

Other popular scientific news websites link to the same empty page when announcing what at least PubMet summarizes as An extremely energetic cosmic ray observed by a surface detector array, gives the abstract and links to a doi that then goes to the zombie page.

What's so exciting is that a single 240 exa-electron volt (240E+18 eV) charged particle (possibly a proton or light nucleus, until it hit our atmosphere) had the kinetic energy of a tennis ball!

In the past (often in phys.org news items) I've clicked on links in popular scientific news articles that go directly to doi.org's "appology page" indicating that the number has not yet been assigned or linked.

In a half-day or so, these same links start working, so I need to save them and check them later.

Question: How do popular scientific news outlets and google news get doi and doi-like links that lead to zombie pages when first release, but only later actually link to the intended scientific paper?

I'm interested in both:

1. the mechanism by which a doi is issued that doesn't work but will work in the future
2. why, in 2023 this still happens

Looking through google news feed jsut now I see an item that links directly to Science with the url https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095 which combines science.org with a DOI. At the moment the page is empty - it contains a header and footer of the usual Science links but no article in the middle - a zombie page.

Other popular scientific news websites link to the same empty page when announcing what at least PubMet summarizes as An extremely energetic cosmic ray observed by a surface detector array, gives the abstract and links to a doi that then goes to the zombie page.

What's so exciting is that a single 240 exa-electron volt (240E+18 eV) charged particle (possibly a proton or light nucleus, until it hit our atmosphere) had the kinetic energy of a tennis ball!

In the past (often in phys.org news items) I've clicked on links in popular scientific news articles that go directly to doi.org's "appology page" indicating that the number has not yet been assigned or linked.

In a half-day or so, these same links start working, so I need to save them and check them later.

Question: How do popular scientific news outlets and google news get doi and doi-like links that lead to zombie pages when first release, but only later actually link to the intended scientific paper?

I'm interested in both:

1. the mechanism by which a doi is issued that doesn't work but will work in the future
2. why, in 2023 this still happens

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo5095

Screen Shot 2023-11-25 at 9.02.52 AM.png (UTC+08):