Skip to main content

Declining invitation to Should I tell the editor I'm declining a review invitation because the authors are hostile about feedback?

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things such as pointing out typos as a big offenceoffense and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I will decline the invitation. My question is: Should I indicate this reason for declining in my reply to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

Declining invitation to review because authors are hostile?

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things such as pointing out typos as a big offence and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I will decline the invitation. My question is: Should I indicate this reason for declining in my reply to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

Should I tell the editor I'm declining a review invitation because the authors are hostile about feedback?

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things such as pointing out typos as a big offense and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I will decline the invitation. My question is: Should I indicate this reason for declining in my reply to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

added 5 characters in body
Source Link
Snoop Dogg
  • 545
  • 1
  • 4
  • 6

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things such as pointing out typos as a big offence and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I will decline the invitation. My question is: Should I indicate this reason for declining in my reply to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things as pointing out typos as a big offence and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I will decline the invitation. My question is: Should I indicate this reason for declining in my reply to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things such as pointing out typos as a big offence and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I will decline the invitation. My question is: Should I indicate this reason for declining in my reply to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackAcademia/status/1511040915409969159
Became Hot Network Question
deleted 8 characters in body
Source Link
Snoop Dogg
  • 545
  • 1
  • 4
  • 6

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things as pointing out typos as a big offence and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I was thinking of decliningwill decline the invitation but I was unsure if. My question is: Should I should indicate this reason for declining in my reply. to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things as pointing out typos as a big offence and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I was thinking of declining the invitation but I was unsure if I should indicate this reason in my reply. This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

I have been invited to review a paper for a good journal. The paper is certainly on my expertise areas. However, I have reviewed papers for the same authors in the past (and accepted some/most of them), and they tend to be quite hostile and rude in their replies. I try to be polite with my comments, even with the major ones, but these authors seem to take simple things as pointing out typos as a big offence and reply with a very harsh tone. Editors seem to not care at all about this, perhaps because one of the authors is an authority in this area.

I will decline the invitation. My question is: Should I indicate this reason for declining in my reply to the invitation?

This is, in this case, I am a good fit for reviewing the paper but my reason for declining is that I do not want to go through this sort of unpleasant moments again.

Source Link
Snoop Dogg
  • 545
  • 1
  • 4
  • 6
Loading