New answers tagged

10

I think the purpose of (funded) research by undergraduates is to give the participants a taste of what real research mathematicians do: think in good company about interesting questions that no one yet knows how to answer. If a high quality paper (or any paper at all) comes out of this work, that's a big plus. But it's not how to measure the success of the ...


5

In my experience, most projects led by undergraduate students do not result in high-quality research papers, or even a paper at all. Undergraduate students can often work well under the frequent supervision of a graduate student, and I have seen many undergraduate students earn a second-author spot on a good paper. Some graduate students will be able to ...


2

No, it isn't reasonable to expect undergraduates to do high quality research on their own. They are too inexperienced and need to learn a lot about process as well as the topic of the research as they do. I think that funders recognize this and treat the funding as a kind of training, not a way to get the highest quality results. But, to manage the students ...


2

Many (but not all) PhD applications specifically ask for a writing sample. The exact requirements can vary, but in my experience unpublished drafts are typically acceptable. That would be an ideal approach to share your work with them. Otherwise, if they don't ask for a writing sample or allow attaching additional documents, do not try to use a trojan horse. ...


3

In the CV, you can mention it under 'Working Papers', and yes, attach the document as a separate file to the application.


0

In addition to silvado's answer, let me make a few remarks: Submitted is the appropriate status for a paper that has been submitted to a journal or conference and is possibly under review. Don't specify the journal which you have submitted to, because you don't know in advance whether it will be accepted there or not. Once the paper is accepted, you can ...


1

You can definitely mention these manuscripts in your resume or online portfolio. To do that, you give the manuscript title and full author list as it appears in the submission, and mention the word submitted either in a section heading or with the reference itself. If you want to explain more about your contribution to these manuscripts, you can write a ...


0

Yes, it is a positive, but it is impossible to say how much since admissions committees have their own standards and are made up of individuals. But, if you do well in the research and are able to get a good letter of recommendation from the PI then it will certainly indicate that you are serious about learning "stuff" and practicing the art. While ...


0

In addition to the other answers, I would suggest sending a polite follow-up email along the lines of "Professor X, I hope you are well. Would you still have time to meet to discuss summer project work, as we discussed during the semester?" It could very well be that they got distracted and just need a gentle reminder to respond.


-1

Rude? probably, especially in these times of "the less people I meet, the better". Futile? almost certain, for the reasons given by @AnonymousPhysicist . Professors have secretary/secretaries. Call them, set up an appointment, they know the professor agenda and can tell you exactly when you should appear to talk with him, after having agreed a time....


5

It's not rude. It quite probably is futile. Many faculty are not in their offices very often normally. Many faculty are in their offices less in the summer - in particular, they are unlikely to have scheduled office hours. During a pandemic, you might not be able to go into the building anyway. If the professor does not feel safe meeting in person during ...


1

Given that there was a tacit agreement to have a meeting sometime in the summer, an unannounced drop-in wouldn't be unusual. But the real issue is that you don't even know if they will be in their office during the summer. COVID is still forcing several campuses to stay remote and have less than full attendance. Several professors are still conducting all ...


1

A person with a bachelors degree entering into doctoral studies directly in the US has a long road ahead. First there will be (mostly or entirely) coursework in advanced topics that will give you the background necessary to pass comprehensive exams and assure you have a broad knowledge. Specialization and research only comes later in most programs. Given ...


Top 50 recent answers are included