Questions tagged [supervision]
Questions relating to academic supervision, which is broadly defined as the supervisory relationship between advisors and their students.
336
questions
1
vote
4answers
150 views
Asking my supervisor to be frank and give feedback [closed]
I am doing my PhD in the Britain and I've got a lovely supervisor which is like a friend for me. I want to ask her to give me direct feedback and tell me directly if I am doing bullshit or about any ...
82
votes
4answers
14k views
Am I being exploited by my supervisor?
It has been 4.5 years since I joined as a PhD student.
My supervisor asks me to draft almost all of his important emails. He will begin by briefing me the issue, and ask me to draft the email in a ...
3
votes
1answer
151 views
PhD supervisor will not read draft
I just wanted to get some input from the community about an issue I have run into with my main PhD supervisor.
I started my PhD about two years ago (hard science field), and about six months ago I ...
1
vote
0answers
45 views
Potential Collaborators insisting on Joining Supervision Panel
TLDR: Researchers wanting to join supervisory team instead of collaborating, why?
I have started my PhD for awhile now and I am gearing up for my confirmation presentation (research proposal defence)....
0
votes
1answer
187 views
What do you think of the reply and do you think he is interested in me and my application?
Recently i have been applying to various Ph.D. programs and i have approached many professors as my potential supervisors and among those, i applied to Harvard and this is what the Director of the ...
0
votes
0answers
120 views
MA Supervisor who arrogant and unhelpful
I need to start with the fact that the MA I'm enrolled in is overseas, so i have a very restricted visa and moved my family here to get this degree. I have a previous MA in a different subject and am ...
7
votes
2answers
461 views
How to work with a student who has a tendency to overcomplicate things? [closed]
I am supervising a senior reading course. As I cannot give a name to a problem I am having with one of the students, I will give an example.
We are reading a paper, and he was not making progress. He ...
6
votes
1answer
91 views
PhD supervision in the Netherlands: what ranks can supervise?
I've heard word that in the Netherlands only a professor/hoogleraar can supervise PhD students but I've found little to solidly confirm this. I've also heard that in practice, other arrangements are ...
0
votes
1answer
70 views
How can I make the most of this opportunity? Any suggestions for a 2nd/3rd year student interested in research? [closed]
I am currently a student about to come towards the end of my 2nd year at University. I had a great professor at the start of the year, and I was interested in trying something outside of traditional ...
-1
votes
2answers
132 views
Can i be a corresponding author? [closed]
I am a PhD student now and i am willing to publish my masters degree research work, but the supervisor is refusing to publish for many reasons concerned him not the quality of my research.
There is ...
1
vote
1answer
104 views
How to supervise an undergraduate reading a paper for the first time?
I am helping supervise a senior student who is reading a scientific research paper for the first time. The goal is to understand a portion of this paper and write an essay presenting the background, ...
1
vote
0answers
30 views
Questions Regarding a Senior Project [closed]
I’m currently supervising an undergraduate senior project in the Department of Physics. I’m responsible for supervising a last year physics student who will be graduating by the end of June. As a new ...
3
votes
0answers
78 views
Old supervisor not responding to email for reference [duplicate]
I have worked with my old advisor for 1+ year to produce my senior thesis. I'd say that our relationship was good when I left to do my masters (and he did write me a reference the first time around). ...
4
votes
3answers
158 views
What's the difference between Advisor and Mentor?
In a lot of Curriculum of undergraduate and graduate researchers I see they list their research experiences using Advisor and Mentor too, to describe that people who guide them in the research.
So, ...
3
votes
2answers
200 views
How to get through with an unsupporting supervisor?
My supervisor does not have time to neither read my report nor give me feedback. The topic I am working on is totally new and my supervisor does not know about that.
There is another guy in my group ...
4
votes
3answers
2k views
Co-supervisor comes to the office to help her students, which distracts me
My co-supervisor (2nd supervisor) comes to the office where I work to help her (main) Ph.D. students. The noise distracts my work. I find it unprecedented. Why not help her students in her own private ...
1
vote
0answers
141 views
Will quitting PhD after six months affect my ability to get another?
I've been at my current PhD for six months but in that time have only had 3 meetings with my supervisor, the last of which was over 2 months ago. Worse than that, I've tried enquiring about our next ...
16
votes
4answers
1k views
Are professors obligated to accept supervisory role? If not, how does it work?
Firstly, I am not specifically talking about PhD supervision. I think that's less relevant for my question since a PhD supervision is usually a mutually beneficial arrangement, as the professor gains ...
11
votes
2answers
723 views
Can a promising graduate turn into a crank? How should their advisor react?
I have noticed from time to time that some PhD students at good, sometimes top, universities (who must have shown promise at some point) start to act as if they're gone a bit crankish. Say, they ...
8
votes
1answer
297 views
It seems that almost all succesfull academics have had distinguished advisors. Is it really true that pedigree defines success?
In his manuscript "The making of a scientist" [1], Hans Krebs highlighted the fact that great scientists are moulded for success by their renowned grad school advisors. Additionally, he talks about ...
0
votes
0answers
69 views
Effective procedures to e-mail a prospective post doc PI for the first time? [duplicate]
I have submitted my PhD thesis in Electronics from the University of Calcutta, India, and am expecting to get my degree within six months. I have published three journal articles, two in Journal of ...
1
vote
2answers
155 views
(Canada) How likely/unlikely is it to get accepted to a direct entry PhD program? [closed]
I am now torn apart between leaving Canada to do a masters program in a foreign country, which will put a huge financial burden on me, I don't even know if I can afford it, and I would also become ...
18
votes
3answers
6k views
Discussing work with supervisor in an invited dinner with his family
I am a grad student. I have been away for an internship in another city. My professor came to meet me at the weekend and he invited me to dinner.
I did not have any time to prepare and I did not bring ...
5
votes
5answers
201 views
Should getting no response in this timespan be understood as a no? What should I do in this situation?
I am starting my Ph.D. and am interested in a specific field of research which seems quite promising for the next years. Now, my masters supervisor does not work in this field, nor anyone in the ...
2
votes
1answer
237 views
Can I present myself as a postdoc at a given institution if I have a supervisor, but no official appointment there?
I have already finished my PhD at X university. I am now a postdoc at Y university and in collaboration with X university (by "in collaboration with X" I mean that I actually have two supervisors: one ...
6
votes
3answers
421 views
How to get on my PhD supervisor's case without becoming a nuisance?
So my PhD supervisor is very senior in the university. This has its advantages but unfortunately this also means he's very busy most of the time, especially now that it's summer and he's been away on ...
1
vote
1answer
558 views
Well-acquainted professor does not respond when I share my work?
I'm a master student in statistics. I took this professor's class, in which I've done very well. I have discussed with him about my research project a few times while taking the class, although he is ...
3
votes
4answers
228 views
How much would an outside second Ph.D. supervisor get paid in the U.S.?
I have been asked to consider being a second supervisor on a Ph.D. project for a doctoral candidate at a U.S. university. As I am in the Netherlands, this does not fall under my normal employment. ...
2
votes
1answer
73 views
Applying for a graduate-level Research Assistantship as an undergrad
I am undergraduate student, applying to be a research assistant for a relatively new professor.
During the interview, after discussing the research project he was currently working on, he made the ...
4
votes
1answer
192 views
Book recommendations for a PhD supervisor
I will start mentoring my first PhD student this fall, and I would like to read some books to have it start the best way possible.
I have already supervised some Master and undergrad students, but I ...
3
votes
2answers
101 views
Best approach to suggest a PhD student from a external collaborator to be her/his PhD co-advisor
In several international collaborative projects I am working, it happens that in some cases I have to teach and do a thorough supervision of PhD students from the other groups. This is something that ...
5
votes
4answers
459 views
Supervisor takes my results to type a manuscript. Is this normal?
I am a PHD student, finishing my candidature in a year's time. The environment of my lab is slightly different. My prof (owner of the lab) does not supervise me at all and I received supervision ...
66
votes
10answers
13k views
Graduate student with abysmal English writing skills, how to help
I am a math professor at an R1 university. I have taken up a new graduate student (my n'th for n<=10), who is mathematically quite strong, but whose writing skills are a couple notches below what I ...
1
vote
2answers
155 views
Should I change my PhD advisor when I find I got not enough advising?
UPDATE: My program is Computer Science and Engineering.
I chose the current advisor for mainly three reasons:
I'm interested in a general research area, and he's in a group doing the stuffs.
He has ...
38
votes
3answers
6k views
As a supervisor, what feedback would you expect from a PhD who quits?
I’m quitting my PhD. The decision has been made. The reasons boil down to diminished interest in the research subject and disappointment with the university’s managerial practices (nothing is done on ...
36
votes
5answers
11k views
How serious is plagiarism in a master’s thesis?
I published my PhD thesis three years ago.
I have just come to know that a master’s student has copied three chapters from my PhD thesis half a year later. My PhD supervisor was also the supervisor ...
47
votes
11answers
17k views
PhD: When to quit and move on?
I am a second year PhD student at a technical / interdisciplinary lab in Europe wondering when to quit and leave a seemingly unbearable situation behind.
My supervisor (a young-ish professor) mostly ...
1
vote
1answer
170 views
How to find collaborators?
Answers to my previous question made me believe that doing research almost exclusively in collaboration is (also) fine.
But how do I find collaborators. It is easy to find researchers active in a ...
0
votes
4answers
118 views
How do I find a supervisor for PhD studies?
I am thinking of doing a PhD. Problem is, I am not a student and the only professors I do know are the ones from the university I took my bachelor and Master's degree. However I was thinking of ...
12
votes
2answers
766 views
9 Years of PhD, bad supervision, no data. What should I do?
I am a PhD student since 9 years. I am working on medical technology where I need intra-operative surgical data. When I joined, I was told that they will have collaboration with hospitals and other ...
11
votes
3answers
2k views
Where do I get advice and guidance from in my PhD if my supervisor is not an expert in the field I am working on?
I decided on my supervisor because he is the only professor working in this field in my country, and he is very resourceful. He helps me out a lot on every aspect other than technical guidance because ...
2
votes
2answers
564 views
Already in grad school, but is grad school for me? [closed]
I'm sure you've seen a dozen variations on this question in this forum, but here's mine:
I've just finished my first year in a top US PhD program in the physical sciences, which I never dreamed I ...
3
votes
2answers
611 views
PhD situation, is there hope?
Next november I will face my third and last year of my PhD. However, my percourse has been torturing and twisted.
I started my PhD in a different group because I was kind of tricked out. My ...
-1
votes
1answer
113 views
An imposed project. How to handle this situation?
So we are working on a sponsored project. My adviser has assigned two fellows to the project, taking the funding of two people from the organisation. However internally, only I will work on the ...
2
votes
2answers
184 views
Ethics behind communicating research after end of project and unemployment
So I have joined my first job in research as a research assistant on an industry-academia collaboration and I am supervised by some professors and a representative from industry is managing the ...
1
vote
5answers
463 views
PhD supervisor stalling research paper submission
I am currently trying to submit a research paper to a Journal, I am a PhD student in his final year.
My supervisor, who provided the data for the research paper and has overseen the whole process, is ...
8
votes
2answers
516 views
(Un)realistic expectations of PhD supervision?
I shall try to make my former question more on-topic and less personal.
When I started my PhD (maths) a year ago, I was having the following (mostly implicit, though) expectations about how working ...
1
vote
1answer
134 views
Are these good reasons for starting a new PhD project? [closed]
If have just finished the first year of my PhD studies in mathematics at a German university. After my master's, which I have done in representation theory, I had started a PhD in a more applied field,...
1
vote
2answers
197 views
Am I supposed to understand my training dataset for a machine learning project?
TL;DR: I am expected to work on a dataset with missing/wrong information about measurement units. Is this a common practice?
Longer version:
I am studying a Masters's program composed mostly of ...
2
votes
0answers
114 views
PhD opportunity | Confusion [closed]
Recently I am offered a Ph.D. position ( Industry Project) in Australia and they want me to join ASAP. (It will be fully funded , fees will be waived off and even I will get monthly stipend)
but my ...
