Questions tagged [rejection]
Questions on rejecting or being rejected, as relates to a manuscript, graduate school application, dissertation, or other academic endeavor.
12
votes
2answers
2k views
Citing a rejected paper in related work
A paper was uploaded to Arxiv that is very similar to my research. I cited it in the related work section of the paper I am currently working on. I was planning on noting the shortcomings of this ...
20
votes
5answers
14k views
How to interpret this rejection email from Journal of American Math Society? Anything to read between the lines?
I had submitted a paper manuscript to JAMS (J. of Amer. Math Soc) and recieved the following email 2 months after the submission. Can you help me interpret this email, as to what the situation is and ...
17
votes
3answers
2k views
How to force a journal to address an associate editor's scientific misconduct?
My manuscript, submitted to a high-rank and very respectable journal, has been rejected by a referee. From the referee's report one could make a conjecture that the referee is one of my competitors, ...
6
votes
1answer
907 views
Is this rejection rude? Should I apply to another position in the same University?
I applied for an adjunct position and never heard back from the school. I emailed them to learn about the status of my application and this is the response I received: Your resume is competitive but ...
7
votes
2answers
214 views
Is it OK to submit the same post-doctoral fellowship application two years in a row?
Last year, I submitted a post-doctoral fellowship application but didn't get it. This year, I thought about submitting basically the same research statement; slightly updated and refined, but having ...
2
votes
1answer
303 views
If a paper gets rejected two times (in two different journals) is that a bad impression if I try to submit in a different journal?
If a paper gets rejected two times (in two different journals) is that a bad impression if I try to submit in a different journal (different from the earlier two)?
7
votes
2answers
633 views
Etiquette on giving negative feedback on a top mathematician's work [closed]
I want to ask a more general question that relates to a renowned mathematician’s recent proposed proof of a famous hypothesis, which seems to be widely considered not even close to being correct – ...
7
votes
2answers
402 views
Offering of a grad class rescinded for incomprehensible reason
A course came up that I was interested in (C*algebras). It's a grad class but was offered to a select group of undergrads including myself. I accepted the offer but then once the class started I ...
2
votes
1answer
341 views
What does it mean when a paper gets rejected stating “poor typesetting” as one of the reasons?
What does it mean when a paper gets rejected stating "poor typesetting" as one of the reasons?
I downloaded a latex template of a journal and used it to write the paper.
When I submitted the paper to ...
31
votes
2answers
3k views
How do I handle plagiarism professionally and emotionally?
So I have been trying to get an article accepted since 2016. It is an article dedicated to a machine learning based prediction of a biological dataset. It was rejected 4 times. Today, on searching, I ...
-8
votes
3answers
236 views
Why are “discretionary” desk rejections generally implemented when they are an obvious bias loophole? [closed]
To be clear I am not referring to out of scope, incorrect formatting or language quality rejections which are mostly detected by junior editing staff and a reasonable explanation is usually supplied ...
3
votes
1answer
119 views
Copyright and Plagairism Policy for Reviewers of a Rejected Paper
I've read today a paper about my research field that seems similar to my submission (rejected) to a conference. It includes ideas, some scientific elements, and concepts but is not exactly a word-to-...
4
votes
1answer
207 views
How common is it for journal to reject a solicited paper?
A guest editor at a peer-reviewed academic journal solicited me to write a paper. I initially hesitated for lack of time. But the editor's invitation was courteous. So I sent an abstract, which was ...
1
vote
1answer
406 views
What should I do if the admission committee has missed something in my application and rejected me?
I applied for a graduate program and I was rejected, but there is evidence suggesting that there was a mistake in reviewing my application. Now the school seems reluctant to reconsider the application....
2
votes
4answers
486 views
Shall I apply again after all my PhD applications are rejected?
I am 29. I've had informative, goal-driven, well written SOP, I'm guessing good recommendations. I have a masters in the related field (Computer Vision) with tier 2 publications. I'm in a research ...
5
votes
5answers
647 views
Advisor threatens to discontinue fellowship. What should I do?
This July I will be in the fifth year of my PhD. I am doing my PhD from India in bioinformatics. Within my four years, one year was for coursework, so that I did not get to delve deep into research in ...
13
votes
3answers
542 views
Dividing paper after Reject & Resubmit decision
In a recent manuscript, we used a first principles calculation A and used it to explain experimental results B. A and B are based on existing methods, the novelty primarily lies in combining them and ...
0
votes
0answers
53 views
Work permit issues for a PhD when switching from one swiss university to another
Recently I was offered a PhD position at University X in Switzerland and I accepted it. I had been giving several interviews at several universities and this was the only decent offer I had in months, ...
10
votes
3answers
557 views
What to do on a desk reject of a revised paper?
Since this is a longer story, let me first give some background:
We submitted a publication to a journal in the field of engineering. The article remained on the status “with editor” for more than ...
6
votes
2answers
318 views
Editorial rejection: should I write back?
I recently submitted a paper to one of the Physical Review Journals (not Letters). I think that the result is both novel and important. After I uploaded the preprint to ArXiv, I received several ...
24
votes
7answers
7k views
How to handle a possibly biased editor?
Suppose a journal editor rejects a manuscript with only one reviewer’s feedback, but the few comments the reviewer and editor made were almost entirely minor comments (e.g. “use these units for this ...
94
votes
5answers
14k views
What should I do when my accepted paper is subsequently rejected?
My paper was accepted for publication in a journal. I have also received an acceptance letter and even I have filled out the copyright form. The corresponding editor first told me "Your paper is ...
18
votes
4answers
417 views
Unethical procedure in methods
I am currently reviewing a paper for a journal and there's a section in the 'Methods' that may raise a questionable ethical concern on animal handling. The paper has a potential contribution to the ...
58
votes
9answers
10k views
Any good way to tell a faculty candidate “We don't want you”?
I serve on a faculty search committee at a large university here in the US. The part of the job none of us enjoys is informing a candidate who's visited and given a teaching demonstration that we've ...
0
votes
2answers
99 views
What does it meant “ assignment of paper with decision in prosess ” in the same time? [duplicate]
I have submitted the paper to JFA journal after the stage "submitted to the journal" (14 days ) ,I have received the message that paper is assigned with current stage " Decision in process " in the ...
2
votes
1answer
335 views
Resubmission of arxiv paper after rejection
I submitted my first paper to a peer-reviewed journal a few months ago. New as I am to the publishing scene, I submitted the paper to the arxiv preprint server before it was accepted. The paper ended ...
5
votes
4answers
2k views
Why are my submissions not accepted by top conferences, while similar papers from others are accepted?
I'm doing my PhD in computer science. I had a few tries for top rank conferences like IJCAI, CVPR and ICML but my paper was rejected from them and consequently I sent the papers to second tier ...
6
votes
1answer
178 views
What to do when you found something new, but don’t have motive/application to justify it?
Last year one of my TAs (a Ph.D. scholar) gave a problem to my undergraduate class, I found the problem very interesting and devoted a lot of time to it. Eventually, I developed a model with my TA ...
-4
votes
1answer
271 views
Can I give up my degree? [closed]
I did a college degree in computer science abroad in England. I only chose this subject because my father did not want to pay for me studying sports. I did not like nor was I good at it. I only passed ...
7
votes
1answer
417 views
If a paper is rejected by many journals before finally being published, will that cause conflict with the reviewers who rejected the manuscript?
I had a manuscript written 3 years before. The results of the manuscript was obtained accidentally while doing some easy trial methods. Although the results were very interesting, but the method was ...
3
votes
1answer
976 views
Conditional acceptance then rejection – worthy of appeal?
We submited a manuscript to an Elsevier journal eight months ago – we basically got a clear straight-forward rejection:
Although the reviewers commented favourably on your manuscript, there were ...
1
vote
1answer
702 views
How to reject a PhD Scholarship offer after accepting it? [duplicate]
I have accepted a scholarship at a certain university, after exchanging many emails with the supervisor. I was interviewed by him and he personally took trouble to secure funding for me. And he also ...
18
votes
3answers
6k views
How to decline a potential PhD supervisor?
I have seen something similar has been asked but I seriously don't know what to do.
I applied to 3 PhD programs all from quite good Universities. For all of them I contacted a potential supervisor, ...
2
votes
1answer
346 views
How do they add you to their blacklist?
I have heard if you send papers to a journal/conferences there are some conditions that might be dangerous for you academic progress! I researched about it but I wasn't able to find a good definition ...
0
votes
1answer
110 views
Express interest to join mentor's group with whom a fellowship application got rejected
I applied for a prestigious US national laboratory post-doctoral fellowship with a potential mentor. Unfortunately, I got rejected. However, I am very much interested in working in this mentor's group....
28
votes
4answers
1k views
Publishing rejected papers
I was reading a blog post, How to reject a rejection, by biologist Claus Wilke where he explains that it is common to resubmit a rejected paper to the same journal after a revision or appeal a ...
3
votes
0answers
153 views
Declining a PhD offer after accepting? [duplicate]
I'm having a bit of a dilemma currently. Basically I applied (with my own research proposal) to three universities for a PhD. Whilst I was accepted at all three, I got no offer for funding from one, ...
7
votes
0answers
116 views
Answer on really valuable review after rejection and invite reviewer into co-authorhship? [duplicate]
Let us suppose that we have received a rejection of our paper form a journal, but this rejection contains a really very valuable and detailed review, so some ideas of this review after some ...
2
votes
1answer
451 views
How to prepare poster paper for conference that rejected full paper
I received a paper reject for a full paper (10 pages) submission in one of the top conferences in CS (distributed systems). I agree with some of the critical remarks, but we felt they should be ...
5
votes
2answers
877 views
How many rejected papers does it take to get an accepted paper?
Today I received my first rejected paper.
The committee of 2 people left some good points but at the end they didn't get the point of my theme. It took me 3 months to write this paper for the ...
34
votes
3answers
3k views
Re-reviewing a previously rejected article but some authors have changed from the previous submission. Should I mention that to the editor?
I recently accepted to review an article for a journal. I actually reviewed the very same article for another journal from where the submission was rejected. This is a rather common occurrence however,...
10
votes
1answer
715 views
Submitting a previously rejected paper to a different journal
I have submitted a mathematical paper for publication several months ago. A couple months after submission, I noticed some mistakes and things that can be improved, but while I sent the unsolicited ...
6
votes
2answers
2k views
What gets a paper rejected after conditional acceptance?
In computer science conferences, the following publication timeline is somewhat common for conferences:
For those who have been involved in program committees, what gets a paper rejected after ...
4
votes
3answers
728 views
I was rejected twice from two MSc programs, should I quit trying?
I received my rejection letter today and I was devastated. I was shocked because I have finally found a supervisor who saw my passion in the field and didn't care about my low GPA and lab members who ...
4
votes
0answers
373 views
Conference issue >> Rejected paper is still in the database/submitted [closed]
Last year I submitted a paper in a local IEEE conference. The paper was rejected. This year I have a plan to submit the modified version of the paper in another conference. When I checked the file in ...
0
votes
3answers
471 views
How to respond positively to a scientist's rejection e-mail (PhD program)?
I am a Molecular biology post graduate from India. I enquire about PhD vacancy to various potential principal investigators (PhD supervisors) by sending my CV and cover letter. When I receive a ...
9
votes
4answers
1k views
Publication- rejection with advising to resubmit
I have received a decision letter from a Q1 journal with following remarks:
Reviewers' comments on your work have now been received. You will see
that they are advising against publication of ...
7
votes
2answers
181 views
Submitting parts of my thesis to a journal, overlapping text fragments: self-plagiarism?
I am currently working on my thesis and I am submitting a part of my thesis as a paper to a journal (same text no rephrasing in some parts). I believe the journal review takes about four to six months ...
4
votes
2answers
1k views
Is it possible for a PhD applicant to be rejected against the potential supervisor's will?
I have been in contact with a potential supervisor in one of tier two US universities before applying and all the way to receiving my rejection letter a few days ago.
The individual department I ...
2
votes
1answer
853 views
Reapplying to a previously accepted Ph.D. program, will this be considered rude?
I looked online and saw one question that was similar, but it seemed like this question was for undergraduate admissions. Another similar question here on academia.stackexchange addressed differing ...
