All Questions
Tagged with erratum or errors-erratum
256 questions
3
votes
4
answers
721
views
Major mistake in my paper on arXiv, counterexample found
I am doing a PhD in an area of mathematics; I uploaded a paper on arXiv a few months back, after finding a mistake last year in an earlier paper of my PhD advisor (a long paper published in a top-tier ...
- 41
6
votes
3
answers
1k
views
Correction of Minor Errors in a Published Research Paper
As a current PhD candidate, I was delighted to have published my first paper two years ago in a journal during my doctoral studies. Subsequently, I left that research group and joined a new one, along ...
- 133
19
votes
4
answers
5k
views
I found a counterexample to one of the intermediate assertions in a proof but not (necessarily) to the overall result – how to publish this?
I am working on a paper which builds upon work from a paper from the 1980s.
In that paper, a result of the form A < B < C is claimed in generality and is necessary for the proof of a result.
I ...
- 683
14
votes
3
answers
3k
views
Is it appropriate to report mistakes in an engineering paper which makes unsupported claims?
I was given a paper to build off of for engineering research. The paper was published in a high impact journal but happens to be written very sloppily in the following sense.
The proof of a central ...
- 683
1
vote
2
answers
158
views
Should I retract my submission to a CS conference after finding a couple of errors in manuscript?
I spotted two errors in my submission post-deadline for the first round of review (the next and final round is a rebuttal round where we can address the reviewers' comments). The errors are as follows:...
- 13
32
votes
13
answers
23k
views
Should I use an author's code made available on request to help retract their highly cited paper?
I am working on an ML-based problem for my undergrad thesis, based on an experimental dataset and prediction results published in a paper two years ago by an associate prof. in a very high ranking ...
- 423
14
votes
4
answers
6k
views
Found significant flaw in my arXiv version paper: what should I do?
I found a significant flaw in my arXiv paper which quite impacts a major part of the conclusion, the paper has not been published anywhere but it has received citations to the arXiv version. Here are ...
- 411
0
votes
0
answers
57
views
Found an error in data after conference paper submission deadline [duplicate]
I submitted a paper to a top conference in my field. I found an error in my data several hours before the deadline. I tried to resubmit. However, the submission website required checking my paper ...
- 1
2
votes
2
answers
297
views
Addressing Errors in Master's Thesis Results and Potential Impact on Degree
I recently completed a Master's course in the UK, during which I submitted a dissertation in June 2023 on machine learning. Unfortunately, I was dealing with some personal issues at the time, which ...
- 21
3
votes
1
answer
151
views
When is an Erratum needed?
A typo, a spelling error etc., in a published paper is definitely not enough for issuing an erratum.
If a mistake destroys a main result, then an erratum is definitely necessary.
What about cases in ...
- 65
23
votes
4
answers
11k
views
Found critical errors in my master‘s thesis after officially submitting
I submitted my master‘s thesis a few days ago. The official deadline is next Friday.
Today I spotted some serious issues in my thesis. In particular, in my main theorem and the main proposition that ...
- 341
0
votes
1
answer
191
views
Using a published paper which has some errors
I have prepared a paper in which I am going to use a set of calculations ( 3 calculations) in my previously published work. In my previously published work I found that one of my calculations was ...
- 3,608
-1
votes
1
answer
144
views
Is peer-reviewing lighter in ACM-SIAM proceedings?
I am having problems understanding some inequalities proved in a paper from the 2019 Proceedings of SODA (annual symposium organized by ACM and SIAM). These proceedings are very helpful and I do not ...
- 155
33
votes
5
answers
13k
views
What should I do after I found a coding mistake in my masters thesis? [duplicate]
I graduated 3 years ago and defendeded my master's thesis without any problem. Since recently, I am planning to go back to academia, so my former advisor and I are working together to publish my ...
- 459
0
votes
1
answer
111
views
How do I go about correcting numbers in my accepted conference paper?
I have submitted a working paper to a conference. The working paper was accepted and I was asked to submit the final version.
During further data analysis I noticed a small error in my code (...
- 1
3
votes
1
answer
374
views
How are the effects of published errors accounted for?
Imagine a researcher publishing a paper that contains a key error in some fact or figure. This error slips through review and ends up being cited in future papers. Later, the original researcher ...
- 31
4
votes
1
answer
481
views
What can/should I do when finding several flaws in a published paper that I have not authored?
I recently read a paper that was full of small errors that should have been pointed out during peer review but very obviously hadn't. Issues like the following
insufficient information in the methods ...
- 22.6k
2
votes
3
answers
1k
views
Made a huge mistake in my bachelor's thesis
I recently submitted my thesis and also defended it successfully. But then I found mistakes in the statistical analyses of my research.
When I was doing my bachelor's there was no biostatistics in my ...
- 21
5
votes
3
answers
3k
views
Missed a citation which has a solution to the problem that I worked on
About 4 years ago, before I started my PhD, I published a paper which used a method to improve an existing result. There were 2 papers on the existing result and method which I used for my work and ...
26
votes
5
answers
5k
views
What should I do after finding out my published results were not substantial?
I am currently working (not in academia) after having graduated from college recently. I hope to apply to PhD programs at the end of the year.
I worked with a professor on a paper about a year ago and ...
- 269
0
votes
1
answer
215
views
An error in my graduate school application that the application system allowed me to retroactively correct after submission
I applied to several master's programs in the same school system two days ago. While everything else on my application was correct, I only noticed an error in the number of credit hours I had entered ...
4
votes
1
answer
231
views
Typo in birthdate in PhD application
How serious of a mistake is a typo in the birthdate of a candidate filling a PhD application in mathematics? For example, if the correct date is 08/10/2000 and the submitted one is exactly one day off,...
- 357
0
votes
1
answer
331
views
What about I published a mislabelled figure in a paper?
Recently I discovered that an axis of one the figures from a paper that I published was mislabelled. Unfortunately, the figure also is the graphical abstract. However, the information in the text (...
- 345
9
votes
3
answers
5k
views
Letter of recommendation contains wrong name of journal, how will this hurt my application?
I’m really freaked out. My professors and manager have submitted my LOR’s to colleges. When I asked one of my professors to send me the letter she wrote for me, I noticed that she mentioned the paper ...
- 99
6
votes
2
answers
858
views
Incomplete manuscript with an error published by mistake
I had an accepted paper at a production stage, when I became aware of a technical error, which I was able to fix (in case it matters: the field is mathematics, and even though the claims I made in my ...
- 651
4
votes
1
answer
310
views
Example of widely accepted and later refuted proof [closed]
I'm looking for an example of the following situation:
Proof of some statement that was widely accepted for a noticeable amount of time (say, at least 10 years).
The proof was later refuted (i.e. the ...
- 196
6
votes
2
answers
1k
views
Are there small citation mistakes in published papers and how serious are they? How often are they spotted?
I have read that even in published papers there are citation mistakes such as putting an incorrect word in cited text, missing a word, etc. I have even noticed these mistakes myself in some papers.
...
- 169
12
votes
1
answer
5k
views
Found a mistake in a published paper at IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics
I discussed with my supervisors and all of them agreed that there is undoubtedly a mistake in part of the measurements of a recently published paper. The idea and the novelty of this paper is correct. ...
- 121
8
votes
6
answers
4k
views
Several mistakes in published work: Advice
I am a beginning scholar. I recently published my first article in my field in a very good journal. The peer review went incredibly smoothly with basically no need for revisions (one reviewer gave a ...
- 91
0
votes
1
answer
455
views
How/where to cite corrigendum publication on CV?
Citations for my publications on my CV are listed in reverse chronological order, and I am wondering how/where to list the citation for a corrigendum.
Should I list the corrigendum and original ...
3
votes
1
answer
197
views
Maintaining a list of minor errata / corrections / comments
I am wondering what options there are for maintaining a list of errata / minor misprints / clarifications to published research papers. Here, I mean errors/misprints that are not sufficiently serious ...
- 191
0
votes
3
answers
148
views
Is it possible to face future problems performing calculations based on possibly wrong data from the paper of other authors?
I published a paper and measured the environmental impact of some chemicals based on parameters published elsewhere by other authors. They are reputed and reliable but I suspect of some ...
- 345
6
votes
4
answers
927
views
Should I send a corrigendum to my paper because values in the supporting material are wrong by an amount that doesn't impact the conclusion?
I recently got a paper published and reported a result in the body of the text that is right. However, this value is based on values in the supplementary material that are extremely close to the right ...
- 345
15
votes
2
answers
8k
views
I found a mistake in my manuscript that is already under review - what to do?
Recently our group has submitted a manuscript with me as the leading author. The manuscript is about computation and modeling, which involves lots of data analysis. Right now the manuscript is under ...
3
votes
2
answers
879
views
Mistake in published paper by others. Clarification needed [duplicate]
There is no work that is free of error and people make mistakes :) But that is not what I am after, I am seeing advise on how to go about asking for clarification.
Recently a paper was published in ...
- 653
1
vote
1
answer
121
views
What's the best way to offer/publish a corrigendum as an independent party?
Context: I do volunteer work doing data entry for an online database of organisms name (not Wikispecies, though I have edited there too). When entering data from published catalogue catalogues, it is ...
- 232
7
votes
4
answers
2k
views
I obtained the code for a published article from its author and found major mistakes in it. What should I do?
I contacted an author to obtain his data and code for a published paper because I could not figure out how he was obtaining some results, given that I was using the same dataset. Once I obtained the ...
- 394
5
votes
2
answers
1k
views
Small unintentional plagiarism issues found after years of my Phd thesis. What can I do?
I finished my PhD in early 2018. I immediately sumbitted an hard copy at the dept. library and a pdf copy on the online database (open-access), a few weeks later as per Univeristy rules.
at the time ...
- 53
-2
votes
1
answer
141
views
acceptance of precision in research papers [closed]
I am implementing a few numerical examples in MATLAB, and I am getting some solutions in which instead of getting exact value 0, I am getting a very small number, such as $10^{-6}$. This seems to be a ...
- 237
5
votes
1
answer
698
views
What happens if a mathematician publishes an incorrect proof of a theorem or conjecture?
I understand that normally the proof is peer reviewed by others before submitting for publication, but what happens if it turns out there was some problem in the proof invalidating it? Is their career ...
- 887
1
vote
1
answer
293
views
I noticed my thesis model is valid only for a specific case, and I've already submitted my thesis, what should I do? [closed]
I accidentally used settings that are not so common (for example, putting a real model of a system in space), and did the whole analysis on that setting. The analysis itself is correct on that model, ...
- 19
12
votes
2
answers
5k
views
What should I do if I find a mistake after I submitted the camera-ready paper?
I recently got one paper accepted. Then I added one paragraph given the reviewers' comments and run more experiments for this section. The problem is that I don't have much time to run the experiments ...
- 2,295
6
votes
1
answer
563
views
On the threshold for an erratum
I've just learned that about five years ago, I made a false claim in the midst of a longer discussion of an example. I didn't include my putative proof of this claim because I was under pressure from ...
- 1,362
5
votes
3
answers
369
views
Do missed patterns warrant correction to a published paper?
hoping some scientist academics out there can provide insight into a question I've been ruminating on for a while.
I spent multiple years working on a large computational data set, and it was ...
- 53
1
vote
1
answer
300
views
What to do if I have found a major issue with my model before a conference presentation?
I submitted an abstract to a major conference in my field. I am presenting tomorrow at the virtual conference and the video is already uploaded, no conference proceedings were submitted. However, ...
- 57
2
votes
1
answer
389
views
How to publish a corrected proof for a claimed mathematical result?
I work in the field of theoretical computer science, and I have published a paper with several results. A few years later, a reader reported to us an error in the paper. The paper claims a theorem X, ...
- 3,990
6
votes
2
answers
10k
views
Is it common for a published paper to have some small mistakes? [duplicate]
I submitted a paper for publication several days ago. This was a resubmission after I had responded to the critique from the reviewers for my first draft. However, while I was looking at my data again,...
- 61
3
votes
0
answers
159
views
Errata on ArXiv [duplicate]
Just a quick question. Is it appropriate to post updates on published papers on ArXiv? I am mostly thinking to use ArXiv as a place where to post papers including corrections (mostly technical typos). ...
- 609
3
votes
3
answers
988
views
Fixing insignificant errors of an article after publication, only in the preprint version
Consider that a paper is published in a journal. It contains some insignificant errors which are not worth asking for an erratum. I was wondering in such a case would it be acceptable to fix those ...
- 1,081
2
votes
2
answers
470
views
When should private tutors communicate with course professors?
Students often seek help from a variety of sources, including private tutors, who can be found either locally or remotely on websites such as Wyzant, Chegg, Tutor.com, Varsity Tutors, etc.
As a ...
- 145