Questions tagged [acknowledgement]

On acknowledging an individual, agency, or institution that contributed funding, criticism, encouragement, or other support to a thesis or manuscript.

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
3
votes
0answers
72 views

Should I acknowledge funding from an unrelated project?

I hold a research position at a university where I'm working on a certain project in a certain field. I met another professor from another field and began working on a new project with him. I'm ...
2
votes
1answer
85 views

Which grants to acknowledge, for papers written over a long period of time?

I often write papers (usually with coauthors) over long periods, say 5-10 years. (In mathematics, this is fairly typical.) Over this time period I've enjoyed a number of research grants, most of them ...
11
votes
3answers
1k views

Is it appropriate to acknowledge Satoshi Nakamoto in a paper devoted to blockchain?

My question is highly relevant to this one: is-it-appropriate-to-acknowledge-stackexchange-in-my-msc-thesis; however, in my case, Satoshi Nakamoto is the pseudonymous person (or persons) who developed ...
30
votes
7answers
7k views

Anonymous reviewer disclosed his identity. Should I thank him by name?

A "friendly" reviewer purposely disclosed his identity to me (the author) during a previous round of reviews of a paper that was not published back then. However, he helped me to make the article ...
44
votes
11answers
13k views

Should I be an author on another PhD student's paper if I went to their meetings and gave advice?

My PhD supervisor (in the field of artificial intelligence) invited me to several meetings with another PhD student. Since I have more knowledge than my supervisor in some topics, I made many ...
3
votes
2answers
221 views

Does my paper need to mention a hired editor?

I wrote a paper intended for a conference in computer science. Before submission I hired an expert to review and edit my paper. Do I need to mention them? If so, in what way? As a collaborator? In a ...
0
votes
2answers
306 views

A professor who is less knowledgeable in certain subjects than a student [closed]

What is a proper way of showing academic knowledge with assignments when your professors and or school is not on par with a particular students knowledge, so-to-speak? A student is extremely smart ...
14
votes
4answers
5k views

Co-author wants to put their current funding source in the acknowledgements section because they edited the paper

In this situation there is a co-author that wants their current funding source added to the acknowledgements section because they edited the paper that others wrote. The research in the paper is ...
0
votes
1answer
96 views

How important is to include an acknowledgment in the poster presentation?

The organization where I work provided me funding for a poster presentation. My opinion is to acknowledge the funding organization due to the research team of an organization is the authors of the ...
21
votes
3answers
6k views

Identity of a supposed anonymous referee revealed through “Description” of the report

I received a referee report from a journal (with single blind peer review policy). If that matters, the journal uses "Editorial Manager" system. By clicking on "View Attachments", one can see 5 ...
1
vote
0answers
170 views

Lot of time an energy spent on a field and lab based Master's thesis but subsequently ignored

I am (was) a mature student with 20 years previous commercial experience Over the course of two extensive field trips plus lab work during my Masters degree I developed and promoted some interesting ...
0
votes
1answer
118 views

Use official titles in Acknowledgements

I am writing the Acknowledgements of my thesis and I would like to know if it's necessary to use the official academic titles. For instance "Thanks Dr.X for his invaluable help in ....", but it could ...
2
votes
2answers
202 views

Can we add an acknowledgment to a paper after it has been published?

Like it has been mentioned, I wanted to know if it is possible to add an acknowledgment after the paper has been accepted We even attended the conferences a few days back
1
vote
3answers
129 views

How do I go about acknowledging my sources of funding when I am supported by 2 different grants equally?

I am a postdoctoral supported by 2 grants (say A and B) with 50/50. Those 2 grants are owned by different PIs. I would happy to have suggestions for the followings: When I finish a paper for grant A,...
1
vote
3answers
171 views

Should my supervisor acknowledge me in his recent paper?

In my chemistry undergraduate I did a project with my supervisor, I worked on it for around 8 months. Around a year later they published a paper on this same topic, after my project was handed in they ...
3
votes
1answer
120 views

How to acknowledge a more general result?

The main result of my paper X (in mathematics) turns out to be a special case of another paper Y. How should I acknowledge their priority without making my paper look worthless? This is the ...
12
votes
4answers
4k views

Copyright statement (US Government) in acknowledgments - what to do as a reviewer?

I am currently reviewing a paper, which has this statement in the acknowledgements: The United States Government retains and the publisher, by accepting the article for publication, acknowledges ...
11
votes
1answer
1k views

What does “thanks x-institute for hospitality” mean in an acknowledgement?

What does The author wishes to thank institute X for hospitality. mean in an acknowledgement? Does it imply that they paid me a hotel or a per diem, or is it enough if they provided me an ...
4
votes
1answer
200 views

Advisors asked for a complete draft of the thesis - should I include the acknowledgement?

I have written an acknowledgement in my PhD thesis thanking my advisors. Meanwhile they have asked for a draft of the thesis (before I submit it). Can I include the acknowledgment in the draft or will ...
2
votes
2answers
172 views

Where to add acknowledgement in Article

I have written an article (2-column type), and would like to put an acknowledgement to acknowledge the non-substantial contribution of a colleague in the analysis of some data. The structure of the ...
7
votes
4answers
856 views

Should I explicitly remind people to include my name in the acknowledgement?

I am a research assistant. I've helped a PhD student from another department throughout her studies by providing and maintaining human cells for her project. She's now about to published, and I'm not ...
8
votes
1answer
851 views

Is it wise for researchers to thank Alexandra Elbakyan (founder of Sci-Hub) in the paper acknowledgements? [duplicate]

Alexandra Elbakyan founded the site Sci-Hub, which allows bypassing publisher paywalls. If this service is used by researchers to access papers that would otherwise be out of their reach - due to ...
5
votes
2answers
248 views

(Soft question?) Sharing knowledge to students, what are the limits?

I am an undergraduate lecturer. I have been bothered by this question lately. I never and never want to claim that what I know, or even what I discover, is mine. Also, things that I discover, small ...
1
vote
2answers
92 views

Should I provide specific acknowledgments in addition to a general acknowledgment?

As a student I wrote a paper for a course. I am now preparing the paper for submission to a journal. My teacher will get a general acknowledgment for the discussions we had on the topic as a footnote ...
1
vote
1answer
174 views

Acknowledgement section

I am tempted to thank the cast of a television show in my acknowledgement section of my thesis. Has anyone else done this?...the show was literally the only thing I would watch while writing...and I ...
1
vote
2answers
324 views

Should I include interviewees in my dissertation acknowledgement?

Background: I am writing a MSc dissertation in a technology/business-related topic. I interviewed 15 people for about an hour each. Each interviewee was given a choice of anonymity (e.g. tech-sector ...
33
votes
8answers
10k views

Why would my former colleagues acknowledge me for a nonexistent contribution?

I spent a postdoctoral period in China, where I faced number of issues with the administration and supervisor. In short, I felt exploited in many ways, from payment and funding restrictions to being ...
4
votes
2answers
184 views

Acknowledgement Page

As an artist and retired visual art professor, I'm updating my master thesis written in 1997 as a hand-crafted art book. Today I'm self-publishing a rewritten thesis as a paperback book to include ...
1
vote
0answers
113 views

Is it unethical to acknowledge a researcher without contacting him [duplicate]

I'm a masters student in mathematics and I gave a seminar talk about my main result. A professor in the audience gave a one sentence comment during my talk. It is an important comment about my work, ...
0
votes
5answers
351 views

Can the supervisor ask a student to add them in an acknowledgment without any useful feedback

I am a PhD student. At the beginning of my study, my supervisor told me that they are able to help me with my topic. However, later I found that they cannot even understand what is my topic. They ...
35
votes
3answers
4k views

Asking for an acknowledgement

Is it ever appropriate to ask to be included in an acknowledgements section of a paper? I contributed bug fixes to proofs in a CS paper without which it would have been incorrect in significant ways. ...
35
votes
5answers
7k views

Should one thank colleagues for interesting discussions that have not actually achieved anything?

I am currently finishing a paper, and I am writing the acknowledgements section. There is a colleague with whom I have discussed several times about the question answered in the paper, who certainly ...
0
votes
0answers
139 views

acknowledgement part of thesis

I am going to prepare the draft my Ph.D thesis and plan to submit it to my PhD advisor. Should I write the acknowledgement part in the first draft, or it must be written in the final draft?
59
votes
3answers
10k views

How to acknowledge a MathOverflow user?

I am writing a research paper. A small but important idea for the paper was found on MathOverflow. I know the real name of the user. I tried contacting him and offered him co-authorship, but I got no ...
12
votes
1answer
2k views

What name should I give to be acknowledged in a paper?

I am a first year PhD student and I was recently working on reproducing some results from a paper which is still being reviewed. In the process I noted a number of issues with the paper which should ...
3
votes
2answers
354 views

Do I need to ask a permission to acknowledge a respected mathematician in my paper? [duplicate]

After writing the first draft of my paper, I sent the proof to an expert in my area. He responded my email in a neutral way, something like: I think if your argument is true then it would be nice,... ...
10
votes
2answers
282 views

What to do about not receiving credit in a paper (lack of acknowledgment)

Recently there have been a few instances of preprints I've seen on arXiv where I felt that I didn't receive due credit (an acknowledgment or at least a mention) for certain things. Here are a couple ...
1
vote
1answer
72 views

What if funding info not uploaded while submission but acknowledged?

To the best of my knowledge, when some authors are funded by some industries, they should (or sometimes have to) acknowledge the industry by writing the funding ID. What happens if someone ...
5
votes
2answers
609 views

Guidelines for When to Acknowledge Research Assistants

I know that it is general practice to include a footnote on papers acknowledging research assistants who have contributed to the project. I am wondering, however, if any guidelines or accepted ...
9
votes
3answers
2k views

Should I inform the people that I acknowledged in PhD thesis? [duplicate]

You write a PhD thesis, in the acknowledgments you thank a series of people from collaborators, to friends, to peers, to professors. Many of these people will never read the thesis so what is the ...
2
votes
4answers
2k views

Can authors/acknowledgements be edited once paper is published?

Following on from my previous question, can the authors/acknowledgements section of a (review) paper be edited once the paper is submitted? Specially adding on people to the authors/acknowledgements. ...
7
votes
1answer
303 views

Should a PhD student be credited in supervisor’s article that is based on a book chapter by both?

Jane is doing a PhD and is supervised by Professor Mary. Mary asked Jane to put together a review article for a book based on a draft chapter from Jane’s thesis with additional suggestions from Mary. ...
0
votes
1answer
78 views

About Acknowledgements part

I had a research stay abroad in an Institute 2 years ago. A short while after leaving institute (about 1 month later) I submitted an article related to my work there to a journal. Recently my article ...
0
votes
1answer
209 views

Carrying incomplete research work from postdoc to assistant professor position

I am a postdoctoral research fellow and recently I got offer for aP position. I am leaving the postdoc position before the completion of contract. My postdoc supervisor is saying that after joining ...
2
votes
0answers
127 views

etiquette/rules regarding acknowledgements and co-authoring of papers?

I have never published a paper before but I am wondering in the case of a collaboration, how this collaboration should be acknowledged to the reader in different situations. Specifically, I am ...
5
votes
1answer
191 views

Literature review and authorship

Let's say a research assistant has provided help on conducting a literature review and that some of the references are eventually used in a published paper. Would the research assistant normally get ...
4
votes
4answers
1k views

How to acknowledge an “anonymous” referee who identified themselves

I believe that I'm in a rather unusual situation and, as the title suggests, there is some uncertainty about how I should acknowledge a particular referee. This referee was supposed to be anonymous, ...
15
votes
1answer
2k views

Before submitting a paper, should I remove acknowledgement for the sake of anonymity?

I have this paper to submit. A professor has given great comments on a previous version of my paper. To submit I need to make it anonymous. Should I also remove my acknowledgement. I think that to ...
2
votes
1answer
547 views

Acknowledgment as technician. Do I list them in the CV? How?

I’m a technician that has done some work in a research group, and I get some acknowledgments in the papers. A fellow technician in the university has told me that for us, technicians, they are ...
6
votes
2answers
640 views

Do you consider it as weird if I thank the open-source community in the acknowledgement section of a paper?

In a PhD thesis I read recently, the author mentioned open-source software in the Acknowledgement section, an idea that I liked very much (I missed that opportunity in my thesis). Now I am ...