1

I recently received a 'reject but resubmission allowed' decision on my paper submitted to IEEE Wireless Communications Letters (binary decision; no revision decision exists)

I wonder how a resubmission process is like.

  • How will the editor consider a resubmitted paper?
    • Will it be considered as a new submission?
    • Will the editor assign the paper to the same reviewers?
  • Should I attach a response document for reviewers' comments?
    • I found no exact place for a response document in the submission system. The closest entries I found are cover letter and supporting document.
  • 1
    In general, reject with resubmission is equivalent to a major revision in other journals; i.e., reviewers think your letter has merit but needs major changes. Try to address the comments, and try again. Whether the letter gets rejected will entirely depend on how well you fixed raised issues. – Prof. Santa Claus Dec 13 '17 at 9:47
2

(1) Will it be considered as a new submission?

Generally, yes

(2) Will the editor assign the paper to the same reviewers?

Possibly to likely (the reviewers are still experts, they already know the paper (reduce work load). However, the editor can change the reviewers, in case one gave a bad review (in terms of quality).

(3) Should I attach a response document for reviewers' comments? I found no exact place for a response document in the submission system. The closest entries I found are cover letter and supporting document.

If possible, attach a point-to-point reply to reviewers. But independent of that possibility, describe the main changes (those that you think will fix whatever caused rejection) in the cover letter.

  • For point (3), yes, attach it as part of the cover letter. I usually make sure the order is such that the responses come first in the compiled pdf. – Prof. Santa Claus Dec 13 '17 at 9:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.