A bit of background: I am working in a R&D department of quite a big name in the IT industry, and we are trying, clashing and combining different ideas and cutting-edge inventions to tackle our engineering problem.

Now the problem itself: There is an excellent paper from CVPR 2017 that I want to try for my project. However, the authors did not publish nor their code, nor their trained FCNN (Fully-Convolutional Neural Network). Now, the project that I am working on is only on the infancy stage, meaning that we need to make some Proof-of-Concept product as soon as possible. Obviously, for this stage, training a deep CNN is a relatively very time-consuming and expensive process, so ideally I would want to ask the authors for the trained model of their FCNN. Of course, if the concept works, we will re-train and fine-tune the whole thing for our specific task, so the author's CNN will not end up in the final product.

Question: How to correctly ask the authors for it? Or is it correct to ask researchers for their results for a project at all?

  • 2
    Write an email to them for the same. I had once written to authors of a NIPS paper that I was involved in extending (improving), within 4 days, they replied back with needful. Usually, they help. Did you check the author's GitHub page, if there is any? – Coder Aug 7 '17 at 18:42
  • @Coder yes, I did check their github repository, and also the common repository of their lab. – FalconUA Aug 7 '17 at 21:38

Just write them a friendly e-mail and include the information you provided here. If they want to share their model, they will, if not, asking didn´t hurt.

Two additional points:

  • Be sure to acknowledge their work when you use it and let them know that you will.
  • Maybe you can offer a collaboration on the work. If their model is usefull to you I guess their knowlegde and know-how in general is. Collaborations with and (co-)funding from industry partners are very valuable for research groups.
  • Thank you for your advise. However, now I am having another problem - they do not respond to my e-mail (have been waiting for few days). Should I treat this as a "no, we can't share with you"? – FalconUA Aug 11 '17 at 11:13
  • I guess you sent an email to the corresponding author? (Meaning to just one guy?) Maybe he is just busy / on a conference / on holiday? Or simply waiting for the next group meeting to discuss this with the others? I would wait at least one week and then try to contact maybe the head of the lab or group / the Professor / senior author. You should be able to find their contact info on the homepage of the university/institute. – asquared Aug 11 '17 at 12:10
  • 1
    @user3352632 writing a short, polite, and formal e-mail is not so easy for non-english speakers, especially if they never wrote a formal e-mail before (I was still a student / intern at that time). – FalconUA Jan 19 at 2:38
  • 1
    So the answer by @asquared 3 years ago has helped me a lot during earlier days of my career :) – FalconUA Jan 19 at 2:38
  • 1
    @user3352632 The academic world for me at that time was fairly alien, so I didn't know how open are the researchers to e-mails like that :) – FalconUA Jan 19 at 2:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.