6

I know that in the US people apply for PhD programs, with a rough a idea in their heads what interests them, as PhD's take much longer and include time to explore the subject.

How does this work for UK students? PhD's usually last for around 3-4 years, and it seems that you would have to know exactly what you want to do when you apply?

I have completed a BA & MA in the Humanities, but I am not sure yet what to write my PhD on. I am sure though that I want to pursue this path.

How does the usual process look like? Would I first contact a professor I would like to work with and then apply to the program? And how specific should my research idea be? I have a certain subtopic of my discipline in mind, and I have also identified a few interesting potential supervisors. However, I am nowhere near having found a proper topic, or an interesting idea which I would want to develop.How do people do this? Sorry if this is a little bit general, but I am a bit stuck!

edit: Let's work on the assumption that I am in the Humanities & that I do not require funding.

  • Do you require funding or do you have funding? (note that UK universities charge a fee). I a good idea of how this works in the sciences, but the humanities may be totally different. – Walter Jun 9 '17 at 12:01
  • Let's work on the assumption that I do not require funding. – Christian Gärtner Jun 9 '17 at 12:26
3

How does the usual process look like?

Differently.

Are you applying for a 3+1 degree? Or a studentship? Or a normal PhD?
(Note: 3+1 (or 1+3) degrees are a combination of a 1-year Master's and a 3-year PhD. Their first year is equivalent to a Master's, and upon satisfactory performance at the end of your first year, you are allowed into the PhD programme. Sometimes the first year is done at one university, and the remaining three years at another university. Example 1 Example2)

Does the application require a research proposal? And/or a writing/work sample? And/or a personal statement?

Do you have your own funding? If not, what type of funding are you applying for? If the funding applications are separate, do they require their own documents?

Etc.

Would I first contact a professor I would like to work with and then apply to the program?

Unless it is a 3+1 course, then normally yes. You would have to find a supervisor willing to supervise you, and to help you properly form your research proposal.
If you are applying for a studentship, then it is likely that most, if not all, the information needed to write the research proposal is already available.

In 3+1 courses, the applications tend to be much more general. They often do not require research proposal, but rather personal and/or research statements. Also, you typically are not required to get in touch with any of the supervising staff, because the topic of your PhD is decided toward the end of your first year.

And how specific should my research idea be?

Research proposals are very specific. It is rare for students to deviate too much from the core of their research proposals during their PhDs.

To get a broad idea of how specific your research proposal should be, I can tell you that your research proposal would need to have introduction, background, aims, methodology, possibly a strategy/schedule, possibly a section about the importance of the research, etc.

But, many people (and most, if not all, successful candidates) get help from their potential supervisors with forming and writing their research proposals.

How do people do this?

I cannot say how other people did it, but the way I wrote my research proposal was I started with a more general idea, then I read a lot about it, which helped me to reduce it to a somewhat specific idea and to find a couple of possibly suitable approaches to achieve this idea. Then I got in touch with a potential supervisor who pointed me to a few recent papers, which further narrowed down my idea to something that looked like a proper PhD project. He then helped me write my research proposal by providing me with tips and very useful feedback.

  • 1
    It might be worth explaining what a 3+1 course is. I'm from the UK and had to google it. – astronat Jun 9 '17 at 12:40
  • does 3:1 mean things like MPhil + PhD, or is it this thing where you start as a Probationary Research Student and then transfer to the PhD? - or something completely different? I have never seen this online anywhere, where it was pointed out like "This PhD is part of a 3+1 Programme", is this usually made explicit? – Christian Gärtner Jun 9 '17 at 13:04
  • @ChristianGärtner Master's followed by a PhD. They are typically advertised as PhDs (example 1, example 2). – 101010111100 Jun 9 '17 at 13:16
  • Can you add the examples to your answer? – aparente001 Jun 10 '17 at 2:40
2

I'll start with the caveat that I'm in the sciences and this got too long for a comment.

You state that

"I have a certain subtopic of my discipline in mind, and I have also identified a few interesting potential supervisors."

That's great! I think the next step for you would be to contact those potential supervisors with a brief email explaining your interests and asking if they are looking to take on a PhD student.

If the answer is yes, you will likely be able to work with that supervisor to develop a specific research proposal. This could be done via email, but I would recommend Skype or meeting in person if possible, just so you can get to know them. When you're ready, you can then formally apply to the department for a PhD position using the proposal you have prepared, mentioning your prospective supervisor's name in your application.

You also state that you do not require funding- I think this will work in your favour, provided you are a competitive candidate (i.e. your grades and research proposal are good). The reasons for this are twofold: one, the supervisor does not have to find money to support you and two, you may be able to start your PhD whenever you want, rather than being tied to a start date dictated by when your funding starts. However, this is something you should discuss with your prospective supervisor.

Note: the academic year in the UK begins in September, and as such you are almost certainly too late to apply to start your PhD this year.

  • So I would just email the potential advisor and then schedule a Skype call to develop a proposal? Would this not be difficult to arrange with a busy professor? – Christian Gärtner Jun 9 '17 at 13:05
  • I don't want to be flippant but if they don't have time for you now I'd be wary of expecting them to make time for you as a PhD student. (To answer your questions though: 1) yes and 2) no. If your email is brief, polite and to-the-point, you can expect a similar reply. My advice is try it and see- there's no other sensible way to go about this.) – astronat Jun 9 '17 at 13:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.