I have not published any papers yet, and I was wondering on the process of writing and publishing an academic papers on different fields, and their differences. I have seen some related posts here, but none that fully summarizes the steps one typically takes to write/publish a paper. I'd like to see how this process may differ in various fields.
closed as too broad by scaaahu, Brian Tompsett - 汤莱恩, Federico Poloni, Buzz, Wrzlprmft♦ Apr 21 '17 at 18:50
Please edit the question to limit it to a specific problem with enough detail to identify an adequate answer. Avoid asking multiple distinct questions at once. See the How to Ask page for help clarifying this question. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
I would say all good research follows the general scientific method, or a tailored version thereof. In some fields the type of experiment and types of analysis are different but I wouldn't say this changes anything major. Research is research after all. The science buddies website is a good starting point to read up on the scientific method.
The answer by @Hosea is a mini version of the scientific method. I'm in the field of engineering and the same process pretty much applies (though in industry you typically do work and then see if you can also publish a paper on it).
In short the scientific method is as follows (from the science buddies website):
If you are aiming for a certain field or journal, read some of the most cited papers over the last year or two in that field or journal, and extract the style, outline, argument and logic flow from there. Your supervisor should also be able to advise you there.
Where you would see a big difference to the scientific method are in the "soft sciences" like humanities and languages.
In the field of Economics:
- Read a lot about a field you are interested in, and come up with an idea/hypothesis for a paper. Perhaps talk to your colleagues to generate an idea.
- Start experimenting and modelling to see if your hypothesis is true. Countless trial and error here, until you obtain satisfactory results.
- Write about the results you've obtained.
- Once you have a draft of working paper, try talking to other professionals in the field to see if they have any insights. Attend some workshops/conferences to present your draft and get feedback.
- Edit the paper according to the feedback you've received until you feel that it's of sufficient quality to be published.
- Choose a publisher/editors to review your paper. If they accept your paper, then revise your paper according to their suggestions and congratulation! You have published a paper.
- If they reject your paper, revise your paper and submit it elsewhere.