7

Oral examination for PhD is common in many countries.

However, most (all?) Australian PhD degrees don't require oral examination. Any particular reason?

3
  • Which kind of oral examination do you have in mind? A comprehensive final examination? The thesis defense? Commented Mar 1, 2017 at 16:59
  • 3
    @MassimoOrtolano from my experience, there is no thesis defense in Australia. So I guess that's what the question is about. And I've always wondered why.
    – Emilie
    Commented Mar 1, 2017 at 20:20
  • This is becoming somewhat out of date, my Univeristy has run oral defenses for the last couple of years.
    – young_man
    Commented Jan 14 at 19:21

1 Answer 1

5

Background: In Australia, PhD theses are examined by at least two external examiners; they must be more than an arms length away from the student or supervisors; e.g., no previous collaboration or have worked recently at the same university. Critically, they must be internationally recognized experts in the student's subject matter. The examiner reports are then deliberated upon by a committee with members drawn from across the university; this means the award of a degree is not done at the school or faculty level.

The examiners serve as independent auditors of the quality of an Australian PhD thesis. They certify/vouch that an Australian thesis is at an international level. They do this by presenting a report that justifies that a thesis contains 'significant contributions that extend the state-of-the-art'.

To achieve the said claim for an oral exam, Australian universities will need to either hold video conferences or fly examiners in. The former is an admin nightmare; e.g., different time zones, getting all involved people to attend/agree, etc. The latter is too expense. Now imagine doing the former or latter for hundreds of theses every year.

Having said that, at my university, oral defense is an option that can be requested by an examiner. This is only for very exceptional cases and rarely granted.

2
  • 3
    A ph.d. from Australia here. The above answer is comprehensive. What I observed while working at many universities in the USA, since my ph.d., the final thesis defense procedure seems to be leaving ways the student can get away with a bad thesis. No need to be peer-reviewed by independent experts in the thesis area, and the thesis committee made of advisor(s) and his/her friends across the university and, rarely, 1-2 friends from outside the university, makes me nervous. Though most thesis coming out of US universities I have seen are still great.
    – John
    Commented Mar 1, 2017 at 21:27
  • In most of the well known North American schools an independent authority inside the university evaluates the credentials of external examiners on whether they are eligible for examining a thesis, this includes, ensuring no collaboration with the student and the supervisors for last 10 years. PhD without defense is a highly dubious process where one can pass a PhD even not writing their thesis, because they are not asked critical questions that ensures that it is entirely their work. Therefore, australian PhDs are usually not of same standard of North American PhDs.
    – N. F.
    Commented Mar 4, 2023 at 17:13

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .