10

I am a first year master student and I am working as a student research assistant with one of my professors. He is nice and very competent. Moreover, I am supervised by a Post-Doc. A few months ago they asked me to do some things related to my work since what I had done was not completely correct. I was upset but went over it since it was the very beginning and what I am doing is completely new to me. Today I had another meeting with them and it seems to me that I disappointed them again since I have to start over again (more or less) and the professor asked the Post-Doc to supervise me more during this phase of the project.

Have you ever been in such a situation? Being wrong in more than one occasion even if the advisor asked you to do something (somehow guided you)?

11

This is part of the process. You will continue to make mistakes. It's likely that all your supervisors made similar mistakes when they were first learning and they likely will continue to make mistakes. Starting over from the beginning isn't ideal in terms of completing research or publishing papers, but it's often necessary, especially if you wish to learn from your mistakes instead of continuing to make the same errors.

I think I spent the entire duration of my master's studies making mistakes. Some of these were errors in estimating how much time an approach would take. Others were misjudgments of expected results. Most of my mistakes, however, were about what people expected from my research. I thought I needed to single-handedly provide enough solid results for a Nature paper. I was clearly incorrect.

I would encourage you, then, to discuss with your advisor what their expectations of your research are. You both should expect to make mistakes along the way.

  • I mostly agree, except if the work was that seriously off-target, why did it take months for anyone to notice? That's a concern. Something else might be up here. – Lightness Races with Monica Feb 20 '17 at 22:26
  • Even without knowing the nature of the work or the conditions requiring re-starting the project, I think it's safe to say that major mistakes are not always immediately apparent. – Harry Feb 20 '17 at 22:56
  • Oh I concur. But I'm concerned at the possibility. It seems to me that the supervisor isn't really supervising very well, as it should be rare that an extreme scenario like this comes to bear. Right? – Lightness Races with Monica Feb 20 '17 at 23:07
  • Thanks all. I do not have a very strong feedback, in the sense that I did not talk to them for 1.5 months. That's why the problem came up only now. I am not concerned with them (they are really good in their field) but the problem is me! Again, thank you. I'll try to talk to them. – wrong_path Feb 21 '17 at 6:06
  • 1
    If you are new at what you are doing and they did not talk to you for 1.5 months there is definitely a mistake at both sides: lack of communication. Set up meetings, at least with the post-doc, regularly. If in doubt with anything, ask for guidance. – skymningen Feb 21 '17 at 9:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.