My undergraduate student told me that he had some problems when he attended the lab session in our department. This lab session is mandatory and one of the components of the course evaluation.

The source of the problem is the lab assistants. They asked him many irrelevant questions about their student union, like the name of the chair, secretary, etc. Unfortunately, he is not a member of this union, so he could not answer. Therefore, they failed him and he has to retake the test.

I want to help my student.

Previously, I considered reporting this case to the chair. However, I remembered that my chair once said that he did not like students who do not join the student union. Hence, I did not report to him.

Do you know the best way to solve this problem with minimum effort?

For further information, the university is located in a developing country in South East Asia.

Note: The union is a student organization. Historically, the union were the response for the repressive regime. To become a member of the union, the student should attend some orientation activity. Most of the activity is hazing.

  • 3
    Is there a "Director of Undergraduate Studies" or similar person whose role is to oversee undergraduate teaching?
    – ff524
    Dec 6, 2016 at 4:26
  • 9
    Do you know the best way to solve this problem with minimum effort? Sorry to sound pessimistic, but I doubt that the problem can be solved even with maximum effort. You are effectively asking how to solve systemic political corruption in a country rife with it. That seems to me to be beyond the powers of this forum. The only practical suggestion I can think of is for the student to join the student union in question, but I'm guessing there are some strong reasons why he does not want to do that.
    – Dan Romik
    Dec 6, 2016 at 6:30
  • 2
    @testes well good luck to you and him both. Maybe you can contact the press, or find some allies within the university who oppose this corrupt system? Anyway, sadly my skepticism remains. You are facing an uphill battle, and unless you are willing to dedicate your life to fighting this injustice, it is likely that nothing will change.
    – Dan Romik
    Dec 6, 2016 at 10:00
  • 2
    There is the slim chance that while the individual might not like people who don't join the union they might still find it ridiculous that, say, chemistry exams or similar are including large numbers questions on irrelevant topics like details of the union. Of course that depends on how strongly the individual feels on the issue and whether they're a generally reasonable person.
    – Murphy
    Dec 6, 2016 at 16:42
  • 2
    If they quizzed and graded him on campus matters as part of a science lab, I think that's ridiculous. Can they provide a list of questions that he failed to answer related to the subject he was being quizzed on? Did they give him feedback on how he could improve his performance? It's also possible that the student gave you an incomplete account of the quiz, i.e. maybe the silly questions were asked but did not count towards the grade. I'd start by investigating the bad grade, i.e. find the evidence that the lab assistants are using to justify giving the student the grade that they did.
    – Gaurav
    Dec 12, 2016 at 7:53

1 Answer 1


From what you have written, it appears that the fundamental problem is that you are dealing with a nakedly corrupt organization. You describe your student as having been failed for blatantly political reasons that have nothing to do with their education.

Such an action is obviously unethical, and should not be tolerated. The key questions that I see, then, are these:

  1. Is there is anybody who you can work with in order to effectively oppose this corruption?
  2. Does your student want to be a test case against corruption?

You describe your chair as being in favor of the current regime. You may wish to discuss in any case, as even if your chair doesn't like students who don't join the union, they may still be opposed to naked abuse of power by union members. If the chair will not act, are there deans or such who might? Are there other faculty members or student organizations who feel the same way as you? What about outside groups that might bring pressure, such as local or international media?

This does sound like an important fight to fight, but also remember that it is not only your fight. If their power is strong and you directly oppose them, the student union may choose to make life very difficult for your student, so before taking any direct action in opposition, it would be important to discuss potential consequences with your student. Since they did not simply take the expedient path and join the union, they may well be willing to fight; equally, however, they may have circumstances that make it problematic for them to do so, and it is not your right to make that choice on their behalf.

  • Thank you for your suggestion. I try to consult to senior faculty.
    – tes tes
    Dec 28, 2016 at 12:11

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .