0

I would like to know what would be the level of novelty that one advisor should ask for an undergraduate student in Computer Science whom is aimed to make an Honours or Bachelor thesis?

For what I have discussed with some colleagues, it would be enough that from the chosen topic the student would feel comfortable for knowing the technique and the experimental methods that he would use. Instead to present something really original that would be in the field of a Master or PhD thesis.

What would be a set of guidelines regarding this issue?

Thanks

2
  • 1
    Speaking from my experiences with 6 universities so far, the answer is that this depends on the department. Some require that there has to be something scientifically new, even in a Bachelor thesis, whereas others consider a nice and comprehensive exposition of existing material on some well-defined topic together with an own and novel presentation to be sufficient for a Master's thesis.
    – DCTLib
    Commented Oct 13, 2016 at 13:11
  • Possible duplicate of What is the Measure of an "Incomplete" Undergraduate Thesis?
    – Buzz
    Commented Oct 13, 2016 at 20:06

1 Answer 1

2

Requiring a new contribution to the field seems like an absurd bar to set for undergraduate students. Not that it's impossible for an undergraduate to do so, but it shouldn't be the minimum standard you expect.

Of course it's possible that computer science is entirely different from my own field (economics), but I find it hard to believe it's that far off. At the undergraduate level you're learning broad foundational material and techniques; at the master's level you're gaining a deep mastery of the material, possibly even focusing in a more specialized subset. Then when completing a full PhD the student takes literally years to produce research that expands human knowledge within the field.

Requiring that a student meets PhD-like qualifications in their undergraduate work seems like it's setting them up for frustration, bad methods, or outright failure. Maybe a truly exceptional student could do it anyway, with the limited time and resources available to them as an undergraduate, and more power to them obviously. But that shouldn't be the requirement set for graduating.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .