0

I am about to get my master's degree and have published a few papers in highly reputable computer science journals. I have gotten an "informal offer" for a PhD position from a world-class university. An informal offer here means that a well-funded professor has e-mailed me, strongly encouraging me to apply and to make sure to mention his/her name in the application so it gets routed to him/her.

For various reasons, I'm leaning towards not pursuing a PhD so I'm currently working on my resume. I'm wondering if it's a bad idea to mention anything about this informal offer in the personal letter. The professor making the offer will not be the one writing my letters of recommendation. Verifying the claim would not be hard, but it's not really a tangible accomplishment. On the other hand, why shouldn't I highlight the fact that I could get into the best graduate program in the world if I wanted to?

closed as off-topic by BrianH, Shion, RoboKaren, jakebeal, gman Sep 24 '16 at 13:47

  • This question does not appear to be about academia within the scope defined in the help center.
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 4
    I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it's for preparation for a non-academic career. This may or may not be considered on-topic at The Workplace, but you should read their FAQ and search for similar questions there first. – BrianH Sep 23 '16 at 20:25
  • @BrianDHall I don't agree, because it can be answered from the perspective of "is this something you can claim as an achievement", not just "is this something that would be valued by non-academic employers." The latter is off topic, but the former seems fine to me. I guess we'll see how others vote :) – ff524 Sep 23 '16 at 20:27
  • 6
    Why shouldn't I highlight the fact that I could get into the best graduate program in the world if I wanted to? Because people care about what you have done, not what you decided not to do. – Nate Eldredge Sep 23 '16 at 20:30
  • @ff524 I read it primarily from the angle of "what would a non-academic employer like to see", which sounds to my ear more like job prep, but I don't feel especially strong about it, so indeed I'm open to how others view whether or not this is on topic here :) – BrianH Sep 23 '16 at 20:32
12

tl;dr: No, you should not mention this "offer."

I wouldn't even call this an informal offer. An "informal offer" would be if you applied, and then were told by e.g. email or phone that you are admitted, and that the formal letter of admission will follow shortly. Encouragement to apply, no matter how strong, is not an offer of admission, and doesn't indicate that you would definitely get an offer of admission if you would have applied.

For example, you may sound great according to whatever information you sent to that professor, but your full application may reveal other things that lead the admissions committee to reject your application. Or maybe you really are that great and the professor has funding, but another, better, student applies that year and gets the offer instead of you.

Furthermore, individual professors have varying ability to actually influence the admissions process, depending on how graduate admissions actually works in that department.

Even for a "real" offer of admission, it wouldn't necessarily be a good idea to list it on a résumé. See for example this related question on listing fellowships that are offered, but which you decline. But being encouraged very strongly to apply to something is certainly not a CV-worthy accomplishment.

  • 4
    "I wouldn't even call this an informal offer..." I agree completely and strongly with this and the subsequent sentences in the paragraph. An informal offer is a kind of offer, and the OP has not received any kind of offer. Trying to "get credit" for something like this could really backfire. – Pete L. Clark Sep 23 '16 at 23:01
  • 1
    I completely agree with you. I had such "offers" from at least 7-8 of the most prestigious universities in the U.S. and I applied for all of them but only 2 admitted me. Those "offers" mean nothing. – somerandomdude Sep 24 '16 at 2:29

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.