8

I am a graduate student in an interdisciplinary psychological field. With the help of a paper I have read today, I have realized that a result of mine is now invalid: I missed a covariate in my analysis and when I include it, my result is non-significant. Fortunately it was not that much about the main point of my conclusion, but the non-significant term happens to be in my abstract title (and my abstract is printed on the abstract book of the conference now!).

I told this to my advisor and he said: “you cannot control every single thing, it is not that important”. But I have controlled it and it did affect my results, and I actually had that particular covariate in my analysis while I was writing the abstract and my advisor told me to exclude it.

I do not know what to do now. I cannot pretend like the result is still there; that conference is very important in my field and I do not want to regret it later. I do not think that it is ethical. I cannot pretend like I did not know that particular covariate is actually important for my analysis, because I have read the paper! I do not know what to do if someone asks me: “why you did not include this covariate?” I do not know whether it is okay to change the title and exclude some results from the poster, even when the abstract (in the abstract book) says another thing.

What should I do? I am very confused and hopeless.

  • 1
    I think the title should be changed. As it stands, I expected a wording or otherwise superficial presentation issue. – O. R. Mapper Aug 26 '16 at 11:33
12

Of course you shouldn't pretend that the result is still significant, when you know now that it isn't. As you have noted, that would certainly be unethical.

Prepare your poster using the results that you believe are correct now. If anyone asks about the difference between the poster and the abstract, just explain what happened. (You aren't the first to make a mistake and catch it later, nor will you be the last.) You can also email the conference organizers to find out if they can update the poster title and abstract (online at least).

Occasional mistakes are common in science, as in everything else; don't stress about it too much, just learn from it for the future. It's great that you caught it now, before your poster presentation, so that you can correct it.

4

No reason to be confused and hopeless. Your question shows integrity and an ethical mindset, so ... own it. After all, science corrects itself and scientists should do so too. And you're right, integrity and trust are too important -- so never try to cover up mistakes.

I highly recommend Sternberg's "Psychology 101 1/2" here:

There is no room in your career for cover-ups. As a lawyer who defended clients accused of various misappropriations once said, it is usually not the original offense but the cover-up that does people in. No one will live a life free of mistakes. You are far better off facing up to these mistakes than trying to cover for them. At times, you may need to issue an erratum to an article you publish, or admit to a serious mistake in your handling of other people, or worse. Covering up is, in my experience, always a mistake.

and later:

My experience in academia is that one can get by just fine being honest. There will be times when it may be embarrassing to be honest, as when you have screwed up. [...] In my experience, it is almost always the cover-up, not the original mistaken act itself, that really cooks people's gooses!

The only thing that still bugs me about your question is the role of your supervisor. If he told you to exclude the covariate and sees excluding it as a non-issue, does he have a different agenda or a conflict of interest? For example, does the marginal point in your findings invalidate major points in his? Is it important for him to ignore that covariate or doesn't he care either way? If the former, then this would be a different problem and then it's not what you do regarding the conference, but what you do regarding your supervisor. If the later, correct the mistake (like @ff524 said, contact the organizers).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.