-1

Recently, I faced a new academic phenomenon that a high level researcher informed me about. I am writing a potential reasoning of the phenomenon:

From a legal point of view, PhD is similar to a transaction in which a PhD student produces an innovative content for the University and, in return, the University will give the student a PhD degree. Thus, it may be concluded that whatever the student produces in these years in direction of his thesis is for University. Moreover, one of the important aspects of a successful research is the potential growth that a research can have (future work). A part of the future work is written inside the thesis; however, many times this part is not such detailed.

Now, suppose that a supervisor wants to take advantage of the future potency of work of the PhD student for the future PhD students of the same University (assuming that the University has the intellectual property of whatever he has produced in direction of his thesis). In this regard, the supervisor may decide to ask him provide a detailed future work list with explanations as a private/inter-lab document so that the next students follow this direction. Is this request legal (based on the Swedish regulations) from a supervisor to his student?

  • Is this hypothetical? – Davidmh Aug 3 '16 at 12:21
  • No, some one explained me that it had happened somewhere in the world and it was new for me; thus, I asked here to check if it is legal. – hossayni Aug 3 '16 at 12:23
  • 5
    Legal? Depends on where it happens. Ethical? Depends on how it happens. "Slave! Write the proposals for PhD students for the next 5 years or you won't graduate!" is not, "dear PhD student, would you mind giving me a hand and share your expert knowledge with some PhD proposals?" sounds OK. – Davidmh Aug 3 '16 at 12:37
  • 1
    Could you please write it as an answer? – hossayni Aug 3 '16 at 13:03
  • 2
    If you are really interested in the legality aspect, then law.se is probably a better fit. If you want to know why a supervisor might ask for this and why a student might want, or not want, to do this, then academia.se is the right place, but an edit is needed. – StrongBad Aug 3 '16 at 16:17
9

A supervisor who asks you to write a detailed "future work" document might be trying to cheat you as you appear to worry about, but it's unlikely.

What's much more likely is that they're interested in the scope for future projects both for students, and for postdocs. If your supervisor can get a grant based on work you've done during your PhD, and there's funding for a postdoc on that, it could well be to your benefit - you should interview well on the topic at least.

Without the backing of your supervisor (either in their lab, or moving on with a reference from them) you're unlikely to have the chance to work on this material anyway, and your dead ends may prove to be good projects for new students with a different skill set.

Finally viewing anything in academia as a simple transaction is rarely helpful model.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.