I'm looking into applying into research/academic internships in defense and intelligence agencies in the U.S. given my previous work experience and my research interest for the next year. All of them unsurprisingly requires letters of recommendations.

I know one professor who could give me a strong recommendation...only that he's native Chinese. Would his background be an issue, raise suspicion, or be a big red flag?

I apologize if this sounds offending. I feel like I'm opening up a hornet's nest. I'm not familiar too much on the academic side of these things. I know if I applied for work with these agencies, the background of this professor would've raised some concerns over any recommendation he could've written.

  • I assume your location is U.S. and you're a U.S. citizen. Do you know if that Chinese professor is a U.S. citizen? – scaaahu May 4 '16 at 13:02
  • 1
    Writers of your letters of recommendation do not have to be US citizens. If that were a requirement I'm not sure I could hire anybody at all these days. – Jon Custer May 4 '16 at 13:43
  • @JonCuster No, of course U.S. citizenship is not a requirement for writing a recommendation letter. The OP is asking if recommendation letter from a foreign professor would be an issue for defense and intelligence agencies research/academic internships. – scaaahu May 4 '16 at 14:10
  • 1
    @scaaahu - I guess I should have been more explicit. I hire into sensitive positions. Many professors who write letters of recommendation are not US citizens, and that does not impact things at all. Some good percentage of folks I work with are naturalized citizens. There is no need to worry. – Jon Custer May 4 '16 at 14:20
  • @JonCuster Naturalized U.S. citizens are U.S. citizens by definition. Many professors who write letters of recommendation are not US citizens, and that does not impact things at all sounds like the answer to OP's question. – scaaahu May 4 '16 at 14:23

For the most part, as long as the recommendation is strong this will not be an issue. Your reliability as an intellectual in the Intelligence Community is a function of your personal characteristics not the nationality of the people writing your Letters of Recommendation. While it is true that substantial affiliation with foreign nationals can raise questions, they are not necessarily obstacles to clearances, so long as your other bona fides are in order (e.g. finances, drug use).

Depending on the area of intelligence, an Letter of Recommendation from a Chinese national may actually help you. If you are an expert on China, or are hoping to work on China as a thematic interest, showing that you have ties to China is no bad thing. Even in the security clearance process, you will need to reveal this association, and doing so up front is only to your benefit.

Far more important is the content of the Letter of Recommendation, and the nature of the relationship. While not a part of your question, these kinds of Letters of Recommendation should be very similar in character to other academic letters. If this recommender would not be your Letter of Recommendation writer for other jobs, I would not make him the writer for this job, either. You want people who know you and your work well, because they will be able to write the best Letters of Recommendation, regardless of national background.

On a side note, while it won't hurt you if your Letter of Recommendation writer is Chinese, if s/he is an American citizen it cannot hurt for them to say so in the letter. It changes the dynamic of the background investigation, just a little.

  • Appreciate the detailed response about this. – JohnDoe24th May 5 '16 at 1:06

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.