6

I would like to know what the difference is between a DOI number and an activated DOI number. Additionally, I have a DOI number for an article of mine to be published in a TUBITAK journal in Turkey. After the actual publication, how long does it take the DOI number to be activated in the system?

Improve this question
0

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
8

Because DOIs are often fairly predictable, and it's useful to have a single ID, many publishers assign them at an early stage of publication, well before the article is online. At this point, though, they're just a string of digits and don't really "become a DOI" until they're entered into the CrossRef system. I'm guessing this is what your publisher means by "activated".

When the publisher has submitted the metadata to CrossRef, the central system at dx.doi.org now knows that doi:10.1234/5678.910 should resolve to www.example.com/journal/article, and the link can start working. Once the metadata is submitted, the DOI should be active fairly quickly - within a day, if not sooner, is my experience. However, some publishers delay submitting this metadata for a while even after the article is first published online in an 'early view' status or similar - I have no idea why, but I've seen it done.

Right now, there is nothing technically stopping publishers submitting the metadata before making the article live, but it's recommended to do so at or shortly after publication - so your DOI probably won't work until shortly after the article is posted online.

It would be nice for DOIs (especially for high-profile material) to be live at the moment of publication... and it may happen fairly soon. CrossRef recently held a consultation on how best to do 'advance registration' of DOIs for unpublished material, and from comments I saw at the time I suspect the responses were fairly positive. This suggests we'll see a more robust approach to this in the near future, with DOIs that are live and resolve to something in advance of publication.

Improve this answer
2
  • Has anything happened in the four interveining years? You might want to edit so that "recently" is replaced by "in 2016" in the last paragraph.
    – Tommi
    Oct 21, 2020 at 6:51
  • 1
    @Tommi it looks like they implemented it shortly after I wrote that reply, but I'm not sure quite how widespread pre-publication submission is now. Will update when I can figure it out.
    – Andrew is gone
    Oct 21, 2020 at 9:23

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .