I noticed that PNAS website contains the section for the so-called "nonresearch articles" (original orthography is retained), otherwise referred to as "collected articles": http://www.pnas.org/site/misc/collectedpapers.xhtml. Upon a brief look at the section and its categories, it seems that articles published there range from "core concepts" articles (somewhat similar to a brief Wikipedia article) to a topic or field review articles and beyond (papers, based on symposiums and other events).

My question is twofold:

  • what is the level of acceptance, if known, for articles, targeting the above-mentioned section;

  • what is the scientific, academic and career value of publishing in that PNAS' section (in other words, is it worth considering targeting this outlet [particularly, for a beginning researcher])?

  • Please note that this question is different from my other question on publishing in PNAS in that the former is about publishing in a specific section of the publishing outlet, whereas the latter is concerned with publishing there in general. Feb 27 '16 at 3:44

I had a look at the latest collection paper (Megafauna and ecosystem function from the Pleistocene to the Anthropocene). This turned out to be a PNAS Direct Submission, which appears to be a pretty standard peer-review process and definitely the standard way to submit papers to PNAS ("Direct Submissions now account for more than 95% of papers submitted and 78% of papers published in PNAS"). I couldn't find out any sort of invitation for collected papers, so my guess is that these are papers that have already been published through standard peer-review, which have been grouped after the fact by PNAS editors. So this isn't a "PNAS section", but just a thematic collection of papers that have been normally published in PNAS (which, in 2014, had an acceptance rate of 17%).

  • I appreciate your nice answer (+1). It has valuable information and insights. However, I suspect that your conclusions might be applicable only to certain, but not all domains, represented in PNAS. Hopefully, my question will pick up some additional interest (I have posted a small bounty for it, but, ironically, it has expired just yesterday) and people from other domains could clarify the situation in this regard. Again, thank you for your feedback. Mar 7 '16 at 0:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.