4

I'm about to finish my Master of Science and I was just wondering around this forum and the question "Is it appropriate to buy a “thank you” gift for a PhD supervisor?" inspired me for this question.

Is a gift appropriate for a MSc thesis supervisor? If so, what gift is more appropriate?

Note: PhD != MSc, avoid marking as duplicate please

  • 3
    As a matter of facts this is indeed not a duplicate. I am well aware of the post regarding the PhD supervisor and I also referenced to it in this post. For them, it's like MSc and PhD are indeed the same thing and the relationship between student and professor/supervisor is the very same. Unbelievable. It's like "he's a newbie, few rep points and all that, he can't read previous posts, he doesn't know how to use StackExchange" whilst this is not true. – AlessioX Feb 6 '16 at 20:43
  • 2
    @O.R.Mapper My original comment appears to have been automatically deleted by the closing process, since I incorporated it into the "Possible duplicate" comment. What I believe is this: the answers for an MSc are the same as for a Ph.D., excepting only that the terminus of the MSc is not a defense and that the scale of a gift (if any) should be proportionally smaller. Recognizing that this might be reasonable to actually state as an answer, I have now changed my mind and voted to reopen. – jakebeal Feb 6 '16 at 23:10
  • 1
    @jakebeal: If the MSc ends with a thesis (as mentioned by the OP), there sometimes is indeed a defense for that thesis. Other than this, I do think there can be a world of a difference between (1) a, say, 6 month MSc thesis that provides an opportunity to show advanced practical skills in action, with a flavour of research, based upon a task provided by a supervisor who may be a doctoral candidate barely older than the MSc student, and (2) a path to a PhD spanning, say, 5 years, based upon largely self-chosen concrete tasks and advice from a supervising professor who can easily be a ... – O. R. Mapper Feb 6 '16 at 23:42
  • 1
    ... decade or more ahead of the candidate, career-wise, and whose advice will mostly be restricted to the research-related side of things, which is in the focus of the candidate, while they are expected to be already well-versed at solving any technical problems of their subject. Now, this is quite culture and location dependent, and probably also somewhat exaggerated compared to the average case, as well as related to individual factors between candidates and supervisors, but IMHO enough to warrant a separate question. – O. R. Mapper Feb 6 '16 at 23:42
  • 2
    @O.R.Mapper I think that your case is covered by the answers to this question. But don't get me wrong: I mildly think that the existing questions and answers cover all the possibilities about gifts to supervisors, whatever the level, and so I voted to close (unfortunately only one duplicate can be suggested), but I'm not strongly against reopening it. – Massimo Ortolano Feb 7 '16 at 0:45

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.