6

In https://arxiv.org/help/prep I found

Indicate number of pages and number of figures. If desired, include Tex flavor or related comments. Do not bother to put "uuencoded" or "gzipped tar file" even if you submitted it this way.

I wonder why this is considered to be helpful. And what are pages anyway? The number of PDF pages? The number of "content" pages (= PDF pages - title page (if any) - blank pages - reference pages - appendix)?

  • 7
    I think this is just because people casually browsing the arXIv like to know roughly how long the paper is before they click the link. (Maybe they are interested enough to read a 15-page paper but not a 50-page one.) – Anonymous Jan 12 '16 at 23:02
  • 2
    To provide basic error checking. – Anonymous Physicist Jan 12 '16 at 23:25
  • 1
    @moose having written a book about longest increasing subsequences, I would totally agree with you. :-) However, as much as figures take a lot of work to create, I still don't think the number of figures is an especially important parameter of a book (for 98% of books at least), and certainly not the most important parameter after the number of pages. For most books this is a nearly information-less statistic and communicating it in such a prominent way is a waste of cognitive capacity. – Dan Romik Jan 13 '16 at 9:48
  • 3
    @DanRomik I remember seeing a Springer GTM as an undergrad (now I forget which) that say "with 1 figure." Naturally I tried to find this figure as it must be so important to merit singular mention, but I sadly could not. When the 2nd ed came out, it omitted any mention of figures. – Kimball Jan 13 '16 at 15:22
  • 1
    @Ambicion When you have a slow connection, the file size matters, not the number of pages. The file size can be determined automatically. – Martin Thoma Aug 22 '17 at 5:27
3

Page length is one of the most basic things you can know about a document, and one of the few useful numerical measurements of a piece of writing. I personally find it helpful as an indicator of how "serious" something is. (This holds for novels as well as papers.) If I see one set of notes on a topic that are 8 pages long versus another set that are 56 pages, I have a good sense that the latter set is much more detailed than the former. Similarly, a 6-page paper entitled "Bounded gaps between primes" (a famously hard problem, very unlikely to be solved in so short a work) gives a very different impression than a 54-page paper with the same title.

While page length is not equated with how deep or interesting something is (and of course depends on format), it can be at least suggestive. As a corollary, I also take page lengths into account when evaluating job candidates to get a sense of how productive they are.

Regarding the definition, I think it's safe to interpret page length as the number of pdf pages, as this is what most people will immediately see when they open the pdf. That said, if it's a book, it's perfectly fine to put something like 286+xvii pages, but I doubt people will care much either way. Remember, this is just a preprint server.

  • 1
    With "format" I guess you mean IEEEtran vs article which makes about 2.5x the difference? Or do you mean A5 vs A4 (vs the american ones) which makes again a big difference? – Martin Thoma Jan 13 '16 at 8:36
  • @moose Format includes all of those differences and others, and no reasonable formatting choice will turn a 6-page paper into a 60-page one. (BTW, I'm in pure math and we almost never use IEEEtran-like formats, and I've never seen anyone use A5. It's rare that I see more than a 50% difference in length because of format choice, and I don't think I've ever seen more than 2x.) – Kimball Jan 13 '16 at 14:19
  • I recently worked in pattern recognition and computer vision. There, IEEEtran (or at least two column designs) seem to be used quite often. On one of my documents, I tried it. When I switched from IEEEtran to article, without changing anything else, I got from 4 pages to 10 pages (no empty pages or something similar). – Martin Thoma Jan 13 '16 at 14:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.