19

I am a graduate student with an assistantship. I met an undergraduate and we hit it off (talking about sex, but not sex with each other). But now I assist a class with her (and I'm not good at hiding my feelings) and she is very flirty. She also put her hand on my arm outside of class (which was welcome). I am performing my job, but I am worried that if things go bad with us she'll claim sexual harrassment. What should I do?

  • 44
    Just don't. Really. – Boris Bukh Oct 10 '15 at 1:45
  • 27
    Wait until the course is over and all the grades published. Make sure you're never going to be a her instructor again. Then, you may ask her out for coffee, but only then. If she comes on to you, tell her to wait until that time. – Stephan Branczyk Oct 10 '15 at 2:09
  • 14
    paraphrasing someone who will surely also say this, run, don't walk. At least while you have any kind of authority over her, this cannot end well for any of the involved parties. – Fábio Dias Oct 10 '15 at 3:03
  • 8
    I thought the question was directed at how to further the interest of a student in the subject material when I saw the title in the hot questions list :( – shortstheory Oct 10 '15 at 11:46
  • 10
    @gfjhjgfhj, Where is that coming from? I didn't tell you to buy her coffee. I suggested you ask her out for coffee (once the grades are published and the course is over). Let her buy her own coffee, or take turns paying for it. It doesn't matter to me. It doesn't have to be coffee either. It's just that coffee shops can usually be found anywhere on a campus. And coffee is super easy to agree to. Just don't offer to study with her, make it clear that you're interested in getting to know her. – Stephan Branczyk Oct 10 '15 at 18:18
40

I am performing my job, but I am worried that if things go bad with us she'll claim sexual harassment. What should I do?

Don't let things go bad. I.e., stop talking about sex, try to hide your feelings, don't flirt, etc. As long as she is in your class, you have a professional obligation to treat her the same as your other students, regardless of whether she welcomes your interest. Doing anything else is dangerous. (Even if she makes no complaint, other students may raise the issue with the administration, if they are upset by it or suspect favoritism.)

In principle, you could try to change your teaching assignment to another class. However, I'd strongly recommend against asking for this. It might not be possible (maybe there's nobody available to switch with you), in which case you'll be in a real mess if you have implicitly announced that your current assignment is untenable. Any changes will be disruptive, which will annoy the professor teaching the class as well as whoever handles the teaching assignments or has to switch with you. Plus the teaching change will be public enough that it will probably create rumors of impropriety.

  • But there are no professional obligations. If they can't use me anymore, they will fire me. – gfjhjgfhj Oct 10 '15 at 10:58
  • 1
    But couldn't she retaliate about a cooling off? I don't think she's that crazy... – gfjhjgfhj Oct 10 '15 at 11:12
  • 9
    @gfjhjgfhj: I'm not sure what you mean by your first comment. The university may not feel any sense of commitment to you, but that doesn't mean professional ethics no longer applies. As for whether she might retaliate about a cooling off, it's theoretically possible (although I hope it's highly unlikely), but if she's the sort of person who might do that, then not cooling off is even more dangerous. – Anonymous Mathematician Oct 11 '15 at 3:15
  • 1
    "Any changes will be disruptive" - this should be bolded, because it is the primary problem here in my opinion. Had classes not begun yet, this should not be much of a problem, requiring only a simple note to whoever is in charge of assigning TAs to courses saying "For your information, I am in a relationship with a student from class X. You may want to consider this for the assignment of tasks." (whether or to what extent that relationship has actually started shouldn't matter, at least as long as the OP doesn't pick a new person of interest from another class during the same semester). – O. R. Mapper Oct 12 '15 at 9:42
16

As a female student who is currently VERY interested in one of her TAs, I have to agree with what everyone is saying: DO. NOT. ENGAGE...

Wait until you are no longer teaching her (and there is no chance that you will ever again teach her), then feel free to accept any invitation to coffee. Asking her to coffee yourself could be risky, if it turns out that she is not as interested as you think. If she likes you as much as I like my TA (who has unconsciously also displayed interest in me, but has been very careful to not show said interest... I have no way of knowing if he is actually interested until after the term is over, when I plan on asking him out), then she will ask you out after the term is over. If she does so beforehand, politely explain to her that it would be highly inappropriate.

At this point, it's not even smart to tell her to wait until the end of the term, because you would still be implying that you like her. You have to act uninterested until the term is over. Period. She will get it. And she will wait. Be patient, and don't obsess or it will show.

12

Under the assumption that you're in the US, it may be the case that you've already violated your school's policy on sexual harassment. It's important to recognize that quid pro quo harassment does also constitute sexual harassment under most (if not all) school harassment policies. Simply put, quid pro quo harassment occurs when a person incentivizes engaging in sexual or romantic activities with him or herself in the workplace. Again assuming that you're in the US, quid pro quo harassment is most likely prohibited by your college's sexual harassment policy. Title IX generally requires college's to have such policies.

As someone who is in a relative position of power over this student, any attempt to initiate or maintain a relationship with her is almost certain to be a violation of your school's policy, and could end up having quite serious implications for you, regardless of how your hypothetical relationship plays out. While you may view this student as being the initiating party, as the person in the relative position of power, it's your responsibility to set boundaries.

From your question, it's not clear to me exactly where you are getting the idea that this person is interested in initiating a relationship with you, so I would avoid broaching the subject directly, however you need to stop any further discussions of the sort you mention as soon as they come up by saying "I'm sorry, but that's not an appropriate topic for us to talk about". It isn't exactly what you're asking, but I can't help but notice that I don't see any evidence from your question that she's actually interested in having a relationship with you anyway. You say that you had a conversation where sex was mentioned, and that she touched your arm once. Neither of those things to me necessarily imply "interested in starting a relationship", though of course there may be other reasons that aren't in your question.

Other commenters here have suggested trying to switch teaching assignments, however I would suggest that that will not entirely mitigate the power differential necessary for quid pro quo harassment to occur. The best way to prevent her from claiming sexual harassment, is to not commit sexual harassment. It's not the answer that I think you want to hear, however it is the answer that you're likely to get from your school's HR/Title IX department.

  • 1
    I am not incentivizing romantic activities in the workplace. I would help her with her work regardless. I should reiterate this to her. Of course there might not be the same interpersonal energy, but this is similar to a star student who arouses the energies of his instructor. How am I supposed to treat her the same when she is smiling, thanking me for doing my job, etc. etc.? She is also a weak student who needs lots of help – gfjhjgfhj Oct 14 '15 at 2:11
  • She may just be basking in the attention. But that is a form of interest to me. I'm not big on the "relationship" bandwagon. – gfjhjgfhj Oct 14 '15 at 2:17
  • 1
    Galen those are the basic facts but the world of the positivist is a subworld of the world of a human. Sorry if I have too much to say here (its a general gift of mine). – gfjhjgfhj Oct 14 '15 at 6:27
  • So what you're saying is that you've given or are giving this student preferential attention on the basis of your perceptions about her attitude towards you? – Galen Harrison Oct 14 '15 at 15:32
  • not academically. She asks for more help in class and receives more help. But there is obviously a difference in cambre while performing the help. – gfjhjgfhj Oct 16 '15 at 22:28
9

Talk with your Professor about this. Depending on the course, the Professor may have some leeway in having another TA take over the grading of her materials and interactions with her, etc.

And if not, it would be good to have your concerns "on the record."

You are very right to be concerned, but you don't have to make decisions (on how to handle the concern) all on your own.

6

In addition to Anonymous Mathematician's fine answer, I'd also recommend that you also take steps to make sure that all of your future interactions with students are in public places where witnesses will be present. For instance, hold office hours in a library or café instead of in a private office. Note that this would be a general policy for all of your students, not just your interactions with the student in question.

  • 1
    Yeah I was never too comfortable meeting with professors of differing genus especially when they closed the door. Luckily, I don't do office hours. – gfjhjgfhj Oct 12 '15 at 0:07
-2

The somewhat cavalier attitude in the question really underlines the lack of understanding of the seriousness of the predicament you currently find yourself in.

This is more than just an issue of loosing or retaining your job. You don't seem to know but you can accused of sexual assault if you are not careful.

You mention that you have talked about sexual matters with this student. Have you done this in front of people? Do you realise what this means?

What if this woman blackmails you for test answers? What if she falsely accuses you of sexual assault? What do you think a police man or women is going to think when they investigate and it comes to light that you where talking about inappropriate sexual matters with this woman in a public setting?

You must realise that in a post modern, 21st century, Sarkeesian era of feminism you will be assumed guilty until proven innocent by the broader public if this issue get to court.

Even if you are found innocent and it comes to light that the whole thing was bogus you will probably still have this huge cloud over your head for the rest of your life.

To conclude. I may have been spelling out the worst case scenarios here. Maybe this woman has a heart of gold and nothing ever comes of it but you cannot be certain of her good nature.

Don't flirt. Don't talk about sex. Do not put yourself or any student in any position that compromises you or the work you do.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.