13

I'm a TA for a class on graduate-level Digital Signal Processing, and one of my responsibilities is to lead a discussion session. It's a 50-minute session that happens once a week, and the professor teaches the class for 3 hours in the week.

The professor had suggested that I discuss the solutions to the homework problems in this session, so today for my first session, that's what I did.

However, I felt this was quite a waste of time, since everyone who had had problems in the homework had come to my office hours and got them cleared, and everyone else in class had managed to do the problems. While I went through solving the problems on the board, I wanted to actively engage the students by throwing in questions about details, what-ifs, some important tricks to remember, etc. But it was a mostly unresponsive, bored-looking class with frown faces.

Should I not go through the homework solutions, and instead focus on important topics covered in lectures?

Also any ideas on how to lead a discussion session in a way that the students who actually managed to do the homework (which is the vast majority of the class) don't get bored?

10

Clear up common points of confusion you've encountered while grading.

If you are also grading homework for the class (or you know the grader...), you can identify common mistakes or points that students seem confused about. Even if you explain these on the individual homework papers on which students made those mistakes, (a) many students don't bother to follow up if they don't understand the grader's comments, and (b) it's possible that other students would have made those mistakes, and didn't only because they made a different mistake instead.

Discussion sessions are a great time to point out these potential pitfalls, warn students away from them, and discuss why they represent a wrong understanding.

Ask a question as a confused person.

I like to challenge a class (in the context of the discussion - not necessarily on an exam!) by asking a question that is ill-formed, confusing, or based on a mistaken premise. (Not to trick them - I warn them that this is what I'm doing.)

For example, I like to find questions asked by Real People on Stack Exchange sites (like Signal Processing Stack Exchange!) related to what I'm teaching, and challenge students to formulate a good answer. Then we discuss the answers as a group.

Answering a "real" question posed in this manner often requires much greater mastery of the material than solving the "nice" problems we usually give students.

Pose a design problem.

On a similar note, the "nice" problems we ask questions often have boring, "nice" solutions that require straightforward application of what they have learned, but not much original thought and critical thinking.

Raising a design problem - i.e. "How can we design a DSP pipeline to do X?" or "Here are two designs that solve a particular problem. What are the benefits and disadvantages of each?". These, too, can come from mailing lists and forums. Here's an example of the type of design problem I'm thinking of.

(Of course, these should be problems your students can solve, based on what they have learned.)

Have students nominate topics for discussion at the beginning of a section.

At the beginning of the session, ask the students to suggest a few topics from the lecture or homework that they would like you to review in greater depth. Then have the class as a whole vote on the nominated topics to determine what to do with the session.

Source of this suggestion: TA handbook for UCSC

Ask the professor to provide you with past exam problems for use in the discussion sections.

Students seem to love working on past exam problems :)

Specifically, you may want to do it as follows:

Hand out a printed copy of the questions (double-sided, stapled). For each question:

  1. Read the question aloud, or ask a student to read the question aloud.
  2. Ask if the question is clear.
  3. Have them discuss the answer in small groups.
  4. Ask for votes, or ask someone to explain their answer.
  5. If the class doesn't all agree on the correct answer, then you can have them discuss further, or you can try to clarify a difficult point.

Source of this suggestion: Jason Eisner

Give mini-lectures about things you think deserve to be retaught.

Especially if you have the time to also attend the professor's lectures, you can identify topics that he may have had to rush through.

Similarly, you may give a "refresher" on a prerequisite topic that students don't seem adequately prepared in.

Or, you can give a mini-lecture on a topic that, based on homework grades, students just aren't getting.

Source of this suggestion: Jason Eisner

  • I think these are all great points! Thank you so much! I especially love the ideas of posing questions from StackOverflow and giving them exam problems. I'm sure you must be a great TA if you're able to do all of this. Thanks for sharing :) – convexityftw Oct 9 '15 at 16:58
3

In general more than 90% students in any class don't prefer to discuss homework problems. Though these are truly necessary to sharpen the understanding, but it could be great if you first discuss something about your professor has already taught and try to get an idea that how many students are really interested in your class.

Many time what happens, many students don't know the benefit of a TA class. Because they just think whatever your proffessor has taught that is enough. So you encourage or convince them that they can interact easily without any hesitation to make clear their doubts or understandings, no matter that is a homework or previously taught lectures.

2

My impression that you should be solving problems, but not the ones from the homework. Prepare some problems that share the same idea, but not exactly the same, and discuss them with your class, or, as ff524 suggested, make use of past exams.

On the specific question of how to get the students involved, I suggest splitting each problem in small and increasingly hard questions. Say, if the bigger problem is focusing on some aspect of amplitude modulation (I'm not keen on DSP), you might ask 'What is amplitude modulation?' as the very first question of the problem. Presumably, everyone in the class knows the answer, but have a student answer this question in front of the audience. This way, you might mitigate their fear of standing out and going to the blackboard.

As an added bonus, you may ask easier questions to the students that are underperforming, and leave the hard ones to the best students in your class.

  • By the way, if you send lots of people to the blackboard at the same time, they can all have fun and not feel self-conscious. – aparente001 Oct 16 '15 at 2:52
  • Hmm, haven't tried that. @aparente001, do you mean asking several people to solve the same problem or asking several people to do several problems at the same time? – svavil Oct 16 '15 at 22:08
  • I mean that each person gets a section of blackboard to show the solution to a different homework problem. I have fond memories of doing this in my Calculus I class. – aparente001 Oct 17 '15 at 0:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.