In computer science in the US, is it harder to get employed as a professor if you've had to do post-docs, or if you decided to work in an industrial research lab for several years?


In many fields these days, it is exactly the opposite: it is hard to get a faculty position until you have spent time as a postdoc. Graduate students are often considered to be simply too inexperienced to become professors. It is also the case that in some fields (e.g., biomedical research) postdocs are a source of cheap labor and professor positions are scarce, so there is a "market" that pushes people toward more and more postdoc.

Industrial labs are a different matter: they may effectively count either for or against you, depending on the situation. In essence: if you are in a postdoc-like position, doing a lot of publications, it's probably in your favor. If you are mostly doing proprietary research that cannot be published, then it's likely to count against you instead.

Specifically in US computer science, the field is currently in transition: historically, there were few postdocs and much hiring directly from graduate school (my own advisor did not even apply for his post). Now, however, the field is moving toward more postdocs before professorship.

  • 2
    In Europe some institutions even formalize this. I have seen junior prof. job announcements that required "between 2 and 8 years after PhD graduation". I have heard that many institutions claim to have been burned by hiring seemingly great people directly out of grad school, which then turned out to be incapable of working on their own agenda. – xLeitix Apr 20 '15 at 13:14
  • @xLeitix Most postings I have seen just require that one has demonstrated the ability to do independent research (with the underlying assumption that this is impossible to demonstrate while working as closely with a supervisor as one does during a PhD). I suppose this might be a difference in fields. – Tobias Kildetoft Apr 20 '15 at 13:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.