7

Grad school application starts now along with all the anxieties associated with it.

One of the question I ask myself and repeatedly get asked by my peers is that what would the profs think when the transcript and resume reveals that they are just an average student (i.e. 3.3 GPA, at minimum of grad school acceptance requirement).

Of course, the top factor here is that we are being evaluated by people who are exceptionally talented and likely the top students back in their days. And plus we may have built an amicable relationship over a long period, no one wants to appear like a useless person. Lastly, there may exist a significant time period between when an application is sent out to when the letter is received, during this time I find a lot of students will question whether the profs are still open writing the letter for them.

What if a professor doesn't like what he sees in the transcript, or feel that the resume does not reflect any exceptional talent, what would a prof usually do in this case?

  • 5
    Even if you're not Albert Einstein reborn, most professors are not out there to destroy you in LORs. An average student may not get more than an average letter, but if they wouldn't support you at all, I doubt they would spend time writing a letter that will actively sabotage your chances. They'll just say they won't write a letter. – Compass Nov 25 '14 at 20:22
  • 3
    "(...) we are being evaluated by people who are exceptionally talented and likely the top students back in their days." Ahem. @JeffE would like a word with you: web.engr.illinois.edu/~jeffe – xLeitix Nov 25 '14 at 20:24
  • @xLeitix likely technically doesn't mean must be :P – Compass Nov 25 '14 at 20:45
12

If you want to go to graduate school and think you will be successful, you should apply. Let the admissions committee decide your package.

I've written plenty of recommendation letters for more "average" students and I suspect most other faculty have too.

The only time I turn down a recommendation letter is if the student really did poorly (e.g., sub-3.0 GPA) in my classes. Then I gently suggest students find another letter-writer. This has only happened once.

Plenty of average students go to grad school and most of them get Ph.D.s. The degree is not necessarily an indication of exceptional brilliance. There are brilliant Ph.D. recipients, and there are less stellar Ph.D. recipients. Instead, the Ph.D. indicates a number of factors, including the ability to do independent research, a great deal of learning and advancement beyond a master's or bachelor's degree, and a huge amount of perseverance.

So I will write a letter appropriate to the student. I will indicate the grade they received in my class, or the research work they did in my group (e.g., "top third" or "top half of the graduating majors").

In terms of writing the recommendation letter, I try to stress positive points, but I am also honest to the admissions committee.

On the other side, the admissions committee knows how to read recommendation letters. There are many graduate programs, and not all programs expect the truly top students. So they can translate your application package into an evaluation of how likely you are to succeed in their program.

5

I have written letters for average students as well, but I consider a few things before doing so. I believe it is easier for me to determine who I will write a letter for or not because I coordinate a tutoring program and have a working relationship with the students.

  1. Did this student make a significant impact on campus?
  2. Did this student contribute something tangible to the program?
  3. Did this student apply training properly?
  4. Did this student maintain their curiosity?
  • +1 Agreed. To write a good recommendation letter, you need something to recommend. :-) – Geoff Hutchison Nov 25 '14 at 21:36
  • 1
    What do you mean by making an impact on campus? – Tobias Kildetoft Nov 26 '14 at 8:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.