I am passionate about working on a particular problem and domain, and have an opportunity to complete a PhD that does not require department/university subsidy. However, the problem I am interested in is outside of the domain of the research faculty. I have been encouraged to find a small part of my problem space that fits with the research of available advisors. However, I feel like conducting my research at another institution, where the research faculty are actively working in the same domain as myself, may be a better choice.

What are the benefits and drawbacks may be to work with advisors directly related to one's own area of research, rather than trying to just fit one's research into the scope of available advisors' research interests?

There is some discussion of this regarding the master's thesis, but I feel that the doctoral level is a little different, in that the advisor/advisee relationship is perhaps more important.

  • Is there some reason you cannot work with faculty external to your department. I've heard of cases where people have two faculty advisers, one in their institution, one outside. Also what does "does not require department/university subsidy" mean? I assume that is a good thing, but I'm unclear what it means. Can you elaborate? Oct 2, 2014 at 20:51
  • Because I'm employed by the university, my tuition is covered as an employee benefit rather than by an advisor's research funding.
    – ybakos
    Oct 4, 2014 at 14:12

1 Answer 1


With regard to choosing to do your PhD research with a group working in your field of interest:-


In-depth subject specific knowledge, meaning that:

You will get started faster.

Your early mistakes and false leads identified and corrected earlier.

You will get a faster entree into the best collaborative networks.

You will get noticed by the community faster.

You will be associated with experts in the field.


Depending on the supervisor, you might get rail-roaded into doing the science his/her "way", leaving less opportunity for you to strike out on your own path.

You are dealing with a new advisor, and that relationship takes time to cultivate.

For your situation, it seems that you will have to get a source of funding.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .