Publishing an article with only three citations on the arXiv [closed]

Question

I wrote a paper about quantitative biology that is 55 pages long and has only three citations. Does this have a chance of being accepted on the arXiv?

Answer 1

As you already noticed, there are papers on the Arxiv which have a very low number of citations. All such papers I have ever seen come from pure mathematics or adjacent fields. These papers (and fields) cite so little, because they do not do introductions providing context embeddings. They can get away with an introduction that is literally: “We consider the problem of X.”

Quantitative biology is not such a field. This is not just an arbitrary convention: Arguably, if you disembed a work of quantitative biology from biological context, you are left with mathematical toying around. For that reason, a reputable journal for quantitative biology is very unlikely to accept such a manuscript without substantial revisions.

Now, the Arxiv is not a journal and has lower standards for acceptance; so this is not a problem per se. If an experienced quantitative biologist produced such a manuscript and just did not bother to write an introduction for whatever reason, it will likely meet the Arxiv’s criteria for publication. But then, this rarely happens and if it does, the authors are completely aware of what they are doing.

The fact that you wrote such a manuscript strongly suggests that you are inexperienced with academic writing and do not have an experienced academic mentor. (Further contributing to this suspicion is the rather high length of the manuscript and that you asked this question in the first place.) All of this in turn makes it very unlikely that you produced academic writing meeting the Arxiv’s standards, and unfortunately the same applies to the research itself.

Now, at this point you might find that I guessed a lot here based on what information you provided and indeed I did. But I am still confident in my conclusion as most of my guesses were already optimistic. For example if you indeed wrote a substantial introduction, the low number of citations makes it almost certain that your writing doesn’t meet the Arxiv’s standards.

Answer 2

Nobody can predict if your paper will be accepted or not to arXiv (which is just a preprint server), because the acceptance criteria is just that your paper is really an academic research paper (and not some homework assignment or plain spam), and that it fits into one of the arXiv topics.

Citations is never considered for acceptance, because it would make no sense, many researchers post their papers in arXiv as a way to make them public, and papers need to be made public before they can get citations.