1

Is it possible to apply for a PhD through a government or a military research laboratory?

If so what would be the process? Is the qualifying exam required? How is that scheduled? How about course work?

  • 2
    Which country do you have in mind? In the U.S., this is impossible unless the laboratory has a close relationship with a university (in which case you would be a Ph.D. student at that university, so you would officially be at a university after all). However, I don't know whether there are some countries in which it might be possible. – Anonymous Mathematician May 8 '14 at 15:13
  • @AnonymousMathematician I think its very country dependent. Definitely possible in the UK, although not that common and probably not at a military lab. – nivag May 8 '14 at 15:35
  • 1
    They aren't military labs, but in the US you can get a PhD from the Air Force Institute of Technology or the Naval Postgraduate School, which are fully accredited institutions. Most of the students are military officers, but they do accept civilians as well, though US citizenship is required. – Nate Eldredge May 9 '14 at 3:08
11

In the US, you cannot have your PhD degree awarded by a government or military laboratory, and similarly industrial labs generally cannot award degrees, either.

However, having worked at several government labs, I can confirm that it is possible to be a grad student and do your thesis research at a government lab. Usually this is done under a co-advising arrangement within an existing collaboration (Prof. X at university A works with Dr. Y at lab B), or under a cross-affiliation (Prof. X has a joint appointment at both university A and lab B).

More specific details differ too much depending on the university and department's regulations, as well as those of the lab in which you're interested in working, so you'd need to ask them specifically. However, it is also worth noting that many graduate departments still have a "residency requirement" on the books—which states that you must spend some number of semesters actually registered as a student at the university before receiving a PhD.

3

I am in the UK so in other countries things may be different.

Some government research institutes fund PhDs, where you are based at the institute for your research. However the PhD itself must be awarded by an academic institution (i.e. a university). You will generally have a supervisor at this university and its name will be on the certificate.

The specifics are going to vary for place to place including: what, if any, taught courses you must do, how often you must visit your university etc. In my experience these factors are often a compromise between the two institutions, particularly the university often has various requirements for the PhD while the research institute just wants you to do research for them.

As for applying, you should expect the same/similar requirements to a standard PhD. when looking for positions the host university or the industrial lab are the best places to start. Although it is not always clear whether the position is just funded by the lab, but based at the university, or actually based at the lab.

A related option, not sure how location dependent it is, is doing an EngD. These tend to be more industry focused, often in a company.

2

There are very few exceptions to this, and those exceptions that exist are usually simply collaborations between an institution and a PhD-granting academic institution. For example, the Danish Council for Independent Research funds PhDs that are hosted at research institutions that do not normally grant PhDs. However, you have to maintain and actually earn the degree from a university, even if you spend the entire time working at the non-academic institution.

Similarly, some institutions that are not universities grant PhDs. For example, the RAND Corporation runs a graduate program in public policy analysis, even though it is not a university and grants no degrees other than that single PhD.

In general, however, you need to be at a research university to earn a PhD.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.