7

I am writing a review for a journal. In the instructions, it contains the following quote: "Your comments may be forwarded in their entirety to the author by the Review Editor, so state your opinions impersonally and objectively".

What does this mean? Are opinions not by definition personal and subjective?

1 Answer 1

27

In peer review, you are asked for your professional opinion. This is distinct from your personal opinion.

The editor would not like personal opinions like "the authors are foolish idiots who must have failed any basic statistics training". The editor would like professional opinions like "the authors did not use a statistical model that accounts for repeated measures in the same subjects, which could increase the risk of false-positive errors; I recommend they use repeated measures ANOVA or mixed effects modeling instead".

The editor would not like personal opinions like "the authors clearly have no idea what is going on in this field". The editor would like professional opinions like "There is recent work by Baggins (ref, ref) and Bombadil (ref) that would help explain the result in Figure 3. The manuscript would be improved if the authors discuss their results in the context of this prior work."

These professional opinions are objective in that they are grounded in your training in the field you work in. They are not based on your hunches and feelings, but based on your expert assessment of the work that is done. They are not based on your personal feelings towards the authors who may have once been rude to you at a conference or forgot to cite your paper or published a paper that supports a theory you oppose. They are based on the work you are reviewing and would be useful feedback to anyone involved: for the editor to make decisions about acceptance, for the authors to make revisions, and perhaps to any other reader.

3
  • Asimov's novella Sucker Bait has an interesting take on "professional opinion". No comment on your answer. Just brought it to mind. Mar 29, 2023 at 18:02
  • Is this orthogonal the choice to use more "personal" language such as "I feel the manuscript would be improved if ..." which can sometimes make it more clear what is my (professional) assessment vs an actual fact? Mar 31, 2023 at 17:12
  • @overfullhbox I think using phrases like "I feel" is not a big problem in reviews, but also doesn't add anything useful so you might as well avoid it.
    – Bryan Krause
    Mar 31, 2023 at 17:18

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .