21

After receiving a rejection (not revise and resubmit) decision from the editor/associate editor of a journal, should we write an email to thank him/her for the time, or just do nothing? I imagine one might do that out of courtesy, but then I don't really have much to say otherwise.

19

I don't recall ever having received such an e-mail as an editor, so it's not standard (let alone mandatory), but I wouldn't be unhappy to receive one. I doubt anyone would care enough to make it worth the effort, but it could be a nice gesture if you feel inclined.

| improve this answer | |
  • This is a nice answer. I try to remember that at the end of the "editor@" email address is actually a real person, often working for free, doing what I think must be the ultimate thankless task. After sharing a few beers with a Nature editor I even pity the professional editors. I'm sure a "thanks for your comments and quick reply" would not go unappreciated. – user2877148 Jun 30 at 7:53
10

I believe that if you feel the rejection was unjustified and you do not plan to submit to that journal again, you do not need to reply.

But if you feel the rejection was justified, you plan to submit to that journal again, or you were helped by the comments and suggestions of the referees, then I would recommend that you write an e-mail thanking the editor and the referees for their time and effort.

| improve this answer | |
5

I think it is reasonable to thank editors that keep you up to date, solicit reviews in a timely manner, and provide an understandable overview of the reviews. Unfortunately, the number of good editors is small, so I would caution against thanking editors for merely acting as editor. The benefits are small while the potential cost is huge. It is so atypical that you run the risk of the editor thinking you are whining.

| improve this answer | |
  • "The potential cost is huge"? I just got a rejection, from an editor who accepted my previous paper, and replied with "Thank you, and happy new year". What's the potential downside of that? – chryss Jan 6 '18 at 19:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.