7

I am applying for a different position in my own department which has better perks and more job security. There is an open search for this position and I am sure it will be very competitive. While I have many recommendation writers outside of my department and University, I was thinking of asking the department chair for a letter of recommendation letter as I have been working closely with him and he has observed my work very closely (and seems to be happy with it).

While I am not afraid of being rejected, I am a little worried that it might be inappropriate to ask the person who is ultimately going to make the final call about this position for a recommendation letter (conflict of interest, perhaps?). Maybe I am being paranoid, but I am very early in my academic career and I am also very excited about this job. Please let me know if you have any good advice. Thank you so much!!!!

1 Answer 1

13

The usual practice in a hiring process is that someone on the selection panel cannot also be a referee for any of the candidates. It is therefore unlikely that your Department Head can give you a letter of recommendation for the position. This actually puts you in a bit of a quandary, since it rules out at least one senior academic that would normally be one of your references, and possibly also other senior academics in your Department. In view of this, it would be reasonable for you to write to your Department Head and ask the following:

  • Can he write you a letter of recommendation in this case, or does that conflict with his selection responsibilities? (Note that you suspect it is probably the latter.)

  • Assuming it is the latter, would he have any objection if you note in your application that you are unable to get a reference from your Department Head (and perhaps also from other senior academics you work with) in order to maintain separation of referees from the selection panel, and you would like the panel to take into account that you are thereby forced to seek references from academics who work less closely with you (and therefore have a bit less knowledge of your work).

In practice ---and notwithstanding formal separation of referees and selection panelists--- the academics on the selection panel who work with you are likely to take into account their own observations of your work in addition to the information in your application. So even if you don't have your Department Head as a referee, he is likely to take account of his knowledge of your performance during the selection process. Consequently, you are not really at a disadvantage from being forced to seek references from people further removed from your work. Nevertheless, just in case there is someone on the panel who is not familiar with you, it may be useful to remind the panel that this is the reason you have not given references from your Department Head, etc.

1
  • 2
    Thank you so much. I will go ahead and ask the Chair.
    – user81883
    Sep 16, 2022 at 15:18

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .