1

I published two papers one is the conference and other is journal paper. The problem is that For same same sample I have to measure same characteristics at two different times. Time gap between measurements is almost one year. Both measurements are not completely similar. Actually both the study was different so that for extension of work I need to take measurements again. I think Results may be different because of long gap of measurements. It could not get same environment. Is it wrong? Will I be caught? I am fearing so much. It’s matter of my career. Please suggest what I can do. Because it’s inferring with conference paper (less valued) then it will not affect journal paper? Journal paper is more important for me. FYI : both the papers are published!

1

1 Answer 1

1

By the same "sample" I assume you mean the same subjects. With a time gap of a year it is completely natural that the results of data collection would be different. Change happens, especially if the subjects are, for example, human. And more so if the experimental conditions themselves changed. Even for quite simple questionnaire data, one can expect different answers from the same subjects over time.

There is nothing to fear from such a situation, but there might be something to explain. That might make the second paper even more valuable.

But it is worth spending some effort to figure out why the data are different and reporting that. Don't forget to cite the earlier paper, of course.

9
  • "But it is worth spending some effort to figure out why the data are different" Exactly that, and then there is no risk of getting "caught", as OP fears. However, unfortunately, in the experimental sciences the underlying reasons for such problems sometimes remain unknown, despite the best efforts to find them. Apr 17 at 17:50
  • Unfortunately I couldn't cite the paper! Will paper be retracted if i caught! I am in fear. pls give enlightenment in this issue.
    – Ansu
    Apr 18 at 19:00
  • Why couldn't you cite the other paper?
    – Bryan Krause
    Apr 18 at 19:35
  • I find its irrelevant to cite!
    – Ansu
    Apr 18 at 19:45
  • I thought its irrelevant bca both the study was different!
    – Ansu
    Apr 18 at 19:52

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .