Recently, an article by one of my colleagues had been accepted at an IEEE conference, and about a week ago, he presented it on the main track. He published a preprint of this paper (without final changes) in arXiv with the following copyright note in the PDF footer, which according to IEEE rules and regulations it looks like permitted to have it on arXiv:
Copyright © 20xx IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works by sending a request to [email protected].
Now about an hour ago, he received an email from the conference chair as follows:
IEEE crosscheck shows that the paper has been published at arxiv. This violates IEEE rules. Asked for confirmation within 24 hours to take down the paper from the web. If no confirmation is received, it is considered that the paper will be excluded from publication and submitted to IEEE Xplore
This sounds very strange to me. Did my colleague violate the IEEE rules and regulations in the first place by putting the paper in arXiv? Or did conference chairs perhaps miss the copyright notice (or the fact that the preprint is actually the original version of the paper) in the preprint version?
In your opinion, what would be the correct next move for my colleague in this case?
Update 1: The paper had not been reviewed under a double-blind review procedure.
Update 2: My colleague replied to the general chair with a complete explanation on how publishing a preprint in arXiv (with necessary copyright notes) is absolutely permitted based on IEEE rules and regulations. Unfortuently, the chair still believes it’s against the IEEE rules and regulations. He responded:
Thanks for the clarification. Make sure your paper have withdrawn by arXiv.
Update 3: ArXiv rejected my colleague's request for withdrawing the paper! ArXiv replied:
Please note that having a paper under review or newly published is not a sufficient reason for withdrawal, as previous version(s) will still be available to users.
arXiv is an electronic repository for research papers, and announced papers are meant to be available in perpetuity. The license applied by the submitter to the work cannot be revoked.
As a result, you request has been denied.
My colleague is now waiting for IEEE's response (contacted authors [at] ieee.org) to see what they can do to fix this issue.
Final update and status: My colleague notified IEEE and they directly contacted the conference chair and asked them to publish the article in IEEE Xplore. The conference chair then sent another email to my colleague after this, something like "After receiving further clarification from IEEE, we will submit your paper to IEEE Xplore." In short: all done! Thank you @jakebeal and others for all your updates, concern, and time