3

If a PhD student were to transfer universities after completing

  1. Course requirements
  2. Qualifying exams

but not yet started a dissertation, could the student start at a new university with ABD status?

Related, would it matter if the exam committee remained the same but the university affiliation was the only difference?

Notes:

  • There are several questions asking about transferring universities after failing qualifying exams, but this one assumes all results have gone well.
  • Unlike this question, the goal would not be to start from scratch, but rather to write a dissertation at a different university.
  • This question is similar but also discusses ABD status as a negative attribute, which is not the intent in this question.
3
  • I would guess each university has its own process, and this is rare enough that many universities do not have established processes. Jul 2, 2021 at 2:05
  • I think it is pretty unlikely and extremely rare that the examining committee would be the same. Normally they are university faculty.
    – Buffy
    Mar 11, 2022 at 20:01
  • Perhaps - but my "qualifying exam" doesn't make me ABD so you may have to double check what the requirements are between departments. Mar 16, 2022 at 17:53

2 Answers 2

6

It is sometimes possible to transfer between doctoral programs and get credit for all the coursework you have completed and for having already passed the Ph. D. qualifying exam. However, I think the odds are probably against it. Getting credit for some of the coursework is generally possible, although many departments place limits on the number of graduate-level credits that can be transferred from another university, and many will also insist that Ph. D. transfer students take the qualifying exam, regardless of whether they had passed it at their original institution.

In my department, we have only given a transferring student student credit for passing the qualifying exam once, and that was in a fairly unusual situation. Our department had hired an endowed chair, and the new chair wanted to bring along her current graduate students, one of whom was quite advanced—finished with coursework and the qualifying exam. The chair wanted the advanced student to get credit for everything she had already done, so all that she would need to complete in our department was her dissertation. In response to the request, our director of graduate studies scrutinized the student's course record and decided that it was satisfactory. Then he and I (who am chair of the committee that oversees the qualifying exam in our department) together looked at the parameters of the qualifying exam in the student's original program, and we determined that it was very similar to the exam in our own department. On the basis of these investigations, we decided to give the student credit for everything she had done in her old program, as her advisor has requested.

So it is possible for this to happen. However, for a student without a powerful sponsor (a newly hired endowed chair is a pretty important person in the department), we probably would not have even considered making a special exception, and we would have required the student to retake a certain number of advanced classes and to take our departmental qualifying exam. Other departments might be more accommodating, but I still think the odds would definitely be against you.

1
  • 5
    Moving to a new university with a professor seems to me to be the most common and only likely circumstance in which this could happen. I doubt that it needs to be a superstar, but the new university will want to do a favor for the new faculty member if possible.
    – Buffy
    Mar 11, 2022 at 20:02
0

As a doctoral supervisor I could say that this is difficult for all involved. The transfer will depend on (1) whether it is a USA institution, or (2) British university, and (3) EU University, or (4) Other. The ultimate answer to your question lies with the respective institution.

2
  • This needs some explanation. Why your four points?
    – Buffy
    Mar 16, 2022 at 18:22
  • The four variables have to do with standards & sequence. While all those degrees are equally validated (in US, if accredited). A US PhD begins with classroom & qualifying exams before moving to the writing stage. The British system is the more traditional research degree which is strictly driven by the supervisor. There may or may not be required classroom time and they will most definitely be travel, hours in libraries, or laboratories, and 100,000 word dissertation versus a 50 or 60,000 word dissertation in American universities. The European Union has its own set of standards.
    – user154513
    Apr 6, 2022 at 12:31

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .