1

Background: My undergrad thesis primarily consists of 4 Methods converted into individual chapters (excluding intro, results, conclusion etc.). One chapter dedicates one specific idea. Each chapter is based on a published/to be published/pre-pint "work". Basically, I have converted each "work" into a chapter.

Now, 3 out of the 4 chapters has 2 additional authors (plus my advisor) but I am the first author in all of them with the major contribution.

Questions:

  1. Is this okay? Should I just leave this as separate papers and leave the thesis altogether? (I don't have the time to develop a separate research and form a thesis out of it.)
  2. Should undergrad thesis work only be based on one author plus advisor?
  3. How does this look front of a PhD CS admit panel? (Say USA).

Additional Reason to build the thesis: The 4 papers are bound by a core specific domain and are quite inter-related in there work.

Note: I have no constraint for course requirements from my university. The thesis is optional. I can drop it anytime. Even at the last second. My university if fine with point 1 and 2. I am asking in terms of phd admit panels and just "in the eyes of other academics" in general.

2
  • 2
    Questions 1 and 2 are dependent on your university's policies and you should ask your advisor about that. I don't see any problem with it personally: my PhD thesis was based on three published papers, one of which I was not even first author for. – astronat Apr 21 at 6:58
  • Thank you, but I actually meant for admits and not my university. I framed the question wrong I guess. I'll change it in the note. – Aymuos Apr 21 at 7:02
2

Since you are not asking about the legalities of handing in such a thesis, I will assume that you have checked that there are no problems obtaining your qualifying degree after handing it in. My answer is contingent on that. I am not in CS, but I don't think the answer is field specific. (in fact it is probably not even specific to academia, but also holds for industry to some degree)

The main question I want answered when I look at PhD applications is:

  • Can this person independently perform high quality work? Or do I have a reasonable expectation that it will be easy to teach the person to do so?

Strong indicators for this are:

  • Consistently good performance in courses.
  • A well-written undergraduate thesis which reflects independent work.
  • A publication based on thesis work, where it is clear that the student was a driving force.
  • Independent projects performed at eg. summer schools.

Weaker, but still good, indicators are:

  • Recommendation letters highlighting the candidate's independence.
  • Publications where it is clear that everything was completely driven by a supervisor, and the student was just along for the ride.
  • Experience working with different supervisors.

Red flags:

  • A weak thesis, not reflecting independent work at all.
  • Poor performance in courses.

If I got an application from a person with essentially no undergraduate thesis, but a compilation of pre-prints with co-authors, my natural question would be if the person has actually done any of this work themselves. I am not hiring the full team who published these papers - I am hiring one student, who is likely the most junior person on those teams. I would need to be convinced that these papers are the product of your work. You could do that by:

  • Specifying your contribution to the individual papers in your application.
  • Actually writing a full thesis, and not a compilation, at mark the papers as "based on thesis X". This would come off very strong, especially if they eventually get published.
  • Having a supervisor write a recommendation letter saying that, yes, you did a lot of work.
1
  • Thank you so much for this answer! This has helped me a lot and not only for this question alone. It was exactly what I was looking for :) – Aymuos Apr 21 at 8:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.