I'm leaving a tenure track position after one year, I have a tenure track offer and a postdoctoral offer. The postdoc position is in the very nice city and I like the research projects there. But the school is not that high ranked. Will going down to postdocs hurt my future transition to faculty position?

  • I do not think this is answerable because so few people have done that. Scrutinize your personal preferences. Commented Mar 20, 2021 at 7:08
  • I know of a case who went from a TT in a small, unknown place to a postdoc in a very famous one to boost their career. No idea if it worked, I didn't follow it. Commented Mar 20, 2021 at 11:49

1 Answer 1


Not necessarily. BUT, is it worth the risk?

Whether a post doc now will help or hurt depends on many things, such as, even, why you are leaving a TT position now and what your trajectory is. A perfect in every way post doc might help, but I'd think that anything less is leaving you on a treadmill without a sure path to progress. And you don't describe this offer as perfect. And, the "very nice city" aspect doesn't contribute to your career and is temporary in any case.

The goal is to get a permanent faculty position. You have an offer of a TT position which puts you closer to the goal. If it is in a place where you would be happy starting your career then take the TT offer.

  • 2
    Living in a nice city may not directly help your career, but if you hate where you live and are miserable for it, that's not a great career boost either. Plus, there's more to life than work. Commented Mar 20, 2021 at 12:18

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .