I have received an offer for an R&D position in a private company. I see that they do quality science, not differently from universities in my field, and they have awesome labs. Plus it’s a fixed term position, I would directly skip the postdoc.

Would such a path allow me to go back to academia in the future, if I will want to? Or would I have to do a postdoc?

This company publishes a lot, so assume that my publication record will be fine.

  • 2
    It depends on the company and the field. Microsoft research and the old Bell Labs (say) certainly allow(ed) you to. – gnometorule Nov 21 at 20:14

Sure it's possible. You just need a strong-enough CV to compare against the people who did do the more traditional postdoc route. Couple of examples of people who did it:

Ivar Giaever became a professor at Rensselaer (RPI) without doing a postdoc, but after accumulating a lot of research experience at General Electric.

Anwar Ibrahim had teaching positions at Oxford, Johns Hopkins University and Georgetown University without doing a PhD or postdoc, but with a lot of government experience.

| improve this answer | |
  • They collaborate with my previous university and they publish as much as academics, and in my same exact field. They’re basically a private research institute and they directly give a long term job instead of hiring Postdocs. – NearIR Nov 21 at 22:40
  • 1
    @NearIR sounds like you'll be able to find a job at a university later, if you wish (don't need to say "find an academic job" since the job at the research institute is effectively an academic job). – Allure Nov 21 at 23:14

Yes, you can do that. But, it might be a mistake to wait too long if that is your real goal. Moreover, consider the issue of letters of recommendation that you might want from academics in a year or so. It would be good to find a way to stay in contact with your advisor and other professors who know about your work and can recommend you highly. You don't want them to have a cloudy memory of you when it comes time to ask.

One way to start out that continuing relationship is to tell them now that you will probably want their help in the future and ask them for any advice they might have. Make sure they understand your long term goal is to return to academia.

Moreover, keeping in contact is a good way to keep open the possibility of future collaboration and start to build your own circle.

I don't know of any field in which a postdoc is required per se. What is needed is a way to buffer from the job market and build a reputation so that you compete with others for open positions. You can probably achieve that with such a position.

| improve this answer | |
  • They collaborate with universities and national labs, so I don’t think that letters will be a problem. I collaborated with them and, besides that they are a private company, they do just the same as we do in academia. They publish in the same field, they go to the same conferences as me, the boss is an editor, etc. They also have labs that you can find in national labs, but rarely in universities. Basically it is a privately run research lab. If - as you users suggest - the postdoc per se is not a formal requirement to go back to academia (in case I want), then it should not be an issue. – NearIR Nov 21 at 22:43
  • And... we’d already be working together with my university on a big international project. – NearIR Nov 22 at 5:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.