11

Some of the graduate programs in US schools require you to submit a diversity statement as a part of the application. I have looked at some resources on writing it, like these ones.

I happen to be from a lower caste in India. Hence there are specific challenges I had to overcome to make it to college. I am not sure if I should talk about it in my diversity statement because there are quite a few professors from upper caste community in the departments I'm applying to and I'm afraid if mentioning my struggle will rub them up the wrong way. Is it a good idea to talk about my background in a diversity statement or is it better to leave it out?

5
  • 4
    Is there any possibility you could discuss this with people from India or an "Indian academia forum"? Most people here are American or European and the caste concept is, I assume, not easily to grasp for non-Indians. – user111388 Nov 21 '20 at 14:25
  • 5
    You point out something interesting (high caste faculty in US). I can't really offer much advice. But this might depend on how strong your application will be without mentioning it. If it is very strong then any possible "red-herring" should likely be avoided. If I understand correctly, your name, alone, might give you away to people of Hindu heritage. In that case, you would be writing for the benefit of others who aren't aware of all of that. – Buffy Nov 21 '20 at 16:04
  • 1
    @user111388 what is a diversity statement? I am European I am not familiar even with this part. I mean, in reality I can grasp what it is, but it sounds astonishing to me. Not that Europe is a paradise but apparently it is not that bad. – Alchimista Nov 22 '20 at 12:01
  • @Alchimista: I agree with you: I also know about the concept of a diversity statement because of this forum here. – user111388 Nov 22 '20 at 12:38
  • 2
    Whether it would actually "rub the high-caste professors the wrong way" is an important assumption, I suspect there is large individual variation. An Indian-raised US professor may view the caste system as outdated, and be more sympathetic to lower-caste struggles (even if high-caste themselves) than a Western-born professor who ignores the whole caste thing. – UJM Nov 23 '20 at 11:25
7

Your diversity statement is not about who you are. It is about why you should be admitted to the degree program. In particular, it is about your ability to work with other people in the degree program and your later career, and how this ability will advance the goals of the degree program.

If your experiences relating to your caste has prepared you to work with other people, including perhaps disadvantaged people, then yes, write about that in your diversity statement.

The fact that there are upper caste faculty in the department is not very relevant. Faculty overwhelmingly come from a higher status background than applicants. There will be many applicants discussing experiences that are unfamiliar and uncomfortable to faculty. Avoid stereotypes and personal attacks.

2
  • 3
    If your application were rejected because you pointed out that low-caste people experience discrimination, then the university is not a place worth studying at. – Anonymous Physicist Dec 21 '20 at 11:29
  • 2
    Regarding your comment: This of course depends on who evaluates the applivation. Where I did the phd, there were some of the greatest researchers in the field who were horrible as human beings. But there were also great people (and I only worked with the latter ones). It could be the same here: Somebody gets offended but it is noone important for OP. – user111388 Dec 21 '20 at 12:35
2

I would recommend including it.

Please note that I haven't ever been involved in evaluating diversity statements, so take this with a grain of salt. This is just my impression based on my overall understanding of diversity statements and the factors in play with them.

While there might be a risk of a high-caste Indian professor seeing a discussion of being from a lower caste as something negative, if you're applying to an American school, I think it's much more likely that the people who analyze your application would be of European or African descent, and would likely be aligned with the Left wing of politics politically, because US academia is dominated by the Left wing in general.

Ultimately, the point of diversity statements are threefold: to show that you're capable of academic writing at the level required by the course, to show that you're willing to bend the knee to the Left wing ideology of intersectional oppression, and to help universities increase their diversity quotas by preferentially accepting students from "oppressed" backgrounds.

I don't want to get into a discussion about whether or not the groups that the Left associates with oppression actually are oppressed or not, because this is the Academia SE site rather than the Politics SE site, but I don't see how mentioning that you were from an additional oppressed group than the ones they usually consider, and that there was another axis for you to be oppressed by intersectional forces, would harm your application, though it may not help it much.

Frankly, the fact your skin is brown rather than white is more likely to be helpful to you - unless the PC brigade at that particular university have decided that Indians are "too successful" and are therefore no longer counted as an oppressed minority, like how Jews and East Asians are often treated, in which case the fact that you're Indian might count against you. In that instance, you mentioning your caste might also be a positive thing because even if they say that most Indians no longer count, then you should, because you're from an oppressed sub-group of Indians.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.