I applied to a job at university A. It happens that a life-long friend (and, much later, professional colleague) is on the hiring committee for that job. Yay for that job. It's for my secondary field though, so while I can see myself getting an interview, I don't realistically see myself getting the position unless everyone else screws up horribly along the interview process which is of course possible as I've seen it happen.

There is also a job at university B that I'm going to apply to. My friend/colleague at A is one of the people whose letters would be optimal given college type, subfields, etc. Except that I also applied to the job at A, and it now feels awkward to ask them for a letter for B.

Were the job market not as awful as it is in COVID times, I would just go with "get a letter from someone else", but the market crunch means I also need to be able to put my best dossier together. So, would it be unreasonable/overly awkward/etc to ask them for a letter, or is this a normal(ish) enough situation to not be concerned about its potential impact on getting a job at A?


In many, and I hope most, places your friend will need to recuse from the decision to hire you even if they don't write a letter. Given that, assuming it is true, getting a letter from them isn't an issue.

But you can ask, first, for their advice on whether a letter from them would be helpful or not. It is even possible, I suppose, that rules would make such a letter off limits for consideration, though I think that would be rare.

It might be that an informal verbal recommendation from them to the hiring committee would carry weight (if not seen as improper), in which case a letter from someone else would be valuable.

But either avoid the issue completely by asking someone else for a letter or explore it with your friend first.

  • FWIW, I've no doubt they will inform the search chair of our history and follow the chair's advice, but given the specifics of the search (which aren't applicable to most fields), I don't imagine they will be asked to recuse themself. Oct 19 '20 at 23:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.