7

Is it ethical to submit to a journal if I know the editor-in-chief?

I'm curious about 3 different cases:

  1. Case 1: We know each other (from talks and emails) but never worked together.
  2. Case 2: We haven't worked together, but are currently in contact about a potential collaboration.
  3. Case 3: If I am one of the editor-in-chief's collaborators (but the paper submitted is not part of the collaboration).

In all cases, I don't know if the editor-in-chief is going to give me an easy time (I am not even looking for that) or a hard time. I mean no promises. I will even ask, in the cover letter, for my paper to be reviewed by at least two referees to comply with my University's regulations (so that I can use it for promotion purposes at my Uni).

3
  • 3
    In well-known science journals, the editor-in-chief is unlikely to see your paper. – Anonymous Physicist Oct 2 '20 at 0:34
  • 1
    @AnonymousPhysicist It is a new journal, and I am sure he would see the paper. But I assume he/she will assign it to one of the editors as stated on the website of the journal. – Fizicklyn Oct 2 '20 at 1:50
  • 20
    Once you've reached a certain level in most sciences, you'll know everybody in your (sub)field. You'll submit papers to editors that are co-authors. Your reviewers may have met you and personally like/dislike you (half the people I asked have been asked to review their own paper at some point by an editor on an offday). Your own paper will be in the special edition you're editing. It's all inevitable. – user3445853 Oct 2 '20 at 12:58
37

There are no ethical concerns about submitting. If there are any ethical concerns, they are completely on the other side. The editor should make some arrangements so that people are treated fairly in the interest of good scholarship. The normal way would be for them to pass all decisions about your paper to someone else.

Editors know a lot of people. Being named an editor shouldn't close out opportunities for those you know and have worked with. But care should be taken so that the process is fair and transparent.

Stepping aside also avoids the possibility that you will blame your "friend" if the paper isn't accepted.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.