1

Suppose, Mr 'X' has a MSc plus 3y PhD degree and only 2 journal publications.

On the other hand, Mr 'Y' has only an MSc degree and 6 journal publications, 3 text books written, and 3 professional books written.

A university/college calls for applications for a position of lecturer or assistant professor, and these two guys apply.

If all other factors are same, who is more likely to get a position?

  • 4
    If there is a strict minimum requirement of a PhD, the second candidate may not be considered at all. – GoodDeeds Jun 10 at 14:51
  • 2
    Depends on whether the second guy will obtain a PhD in the foreseeable future (a few months) or not. – lighthouse keeper Jun 10 at 15:10
  • @lighthousekeeper, What if 'Yes', and what if 'No'? – user366312 Jun 10 at 15:18
  • 1
    If "no", it would probably not be possible to hire him (in most countries I know, I'm EU-based). If "yes", they can probably hire him under the condition that he will complete the PhD in a certain timeframe. Then he might be the preferred choice. – lighthouse keeper Jun 10 at 15:22
  • If we ignore the formal requirements or assume they can be bent, it really depends on the content publications, whether it is a solo-author publication, what are the contributions of each author; the number is not much important – onurcanbkts Jun 10 at 20:56
5

You will have to specify which country/system/subject you are talking about.

In the UK a PhD is pretty much a 100% requirement in most subjects. The only exceptions to this are subject where you would be doing vocational training, such as business studies, management, nursing, perhaps even law(?) where an exceptional standing and experience in the field might make up for a lack of PhD. The other big exception is medical school, where you could have an MD rather than a PhD.

| improve this answer | |
  • You will have to specify which country/system/subject you are talking about. --- UK and Portugal. – user366312 Jun 10 at 15:19
  • In essense I agree, and these days a PhD is very often a formal requirement. Vocational training is quite broad, but yes, in many cases a visiting "teacher/ researcher" with strong industry background can be selected. Few such people have publications etc but hey fall in different category. Also, at least in times past, in Oxbridge some stellar PhD candidates and future renowned academics were given lecturships before completing a PhD and remained Mr/Mrs throughout their career - a peculiar badge of honour. I do not know if that happens these days. – user117109 Jun 10 at 16:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.